McCrossin K E, White H T, Sane S
Department of Anaesthesia and Intensive Care Unit, Logan Hospital, Brisbane, Queensland.
Anaesth Intensive Care. 2014 Mar;42(2):207-12. doi: 10.1177/0310057X1404200207.
The decision to attempt a percutaneous airway in a recognised 'Can't Intubate, Can't Oxygenate' (CICO) situation may occur too late to avoid a poor outcome. Our study was designed to investigate the effect of high-fidelity simulation on the confidence and decision-making ability of anaesthesia trainees in managing CICO scenarios in subsequent simulation. Nine anaesthesia trainees from Logan Hospital participated. Pre-study questionnaires surveying confidence levels in various anaesthetic crises were completed. All participants underwent an education session based on algorithms developed for failed intubation and ventilation, and techniques for securing percutaneous airway access. However, only four of the nine participated in a high-fidelity simulation session. All nine participants were then filmed during 'mini-simulation' assessment sessions and completed post-study questionnaires identical to those at the commencement of the study. The four trainees who had undertaken the initial high-fidelity simulation had a lower median time to laryngeal mask airway attempt (60 versus 115 seconds) and time to percutaneous airway attempt (111 versus 172 seconds) in the subsequent simulation. The median number of deviations from the Difficult Airway Society algorithm was 0 for the simulation group compared to 1 for the non-simulation group. This small study suggests that high-fidelity simulation shortens the decision-making time of anaesthesia trainees in subsequent simulated CICO scenarios. This observation warrants follow-up in larger prospective trials.
在已确认的“无法插管、无法给氧”(CICO)情况下决定尝试经皮气道建立可能为时已晚,难以避免不良后果。我们的研究旨在调查高仿真模拟对麻醉实习医生在后续模拟中处理CICO情况时的信心和决策能力的影响。来自洛根医院的九名麻醉实习医生参与了研究。完成了关于对各种麻醉危机信心水平的预研究问卷调查。所有参与者都参加了一次基于为插管失败和通气失败制定的算法以及经皮气道建立技术的培训课程。然而,九名参与者中只有四名参加了高仿真模拟课程。然后,在“迷你模拟”评估课程中对所有九名参与者进行了拍摄,并完成了与研究开始时相同的研究后问卷调查。在后续模拟中,最初参加高仿真模拟的四名实习医生尝试插入喉罩气道的中位时间(分别为60秒和115秒)以及尝试经皮气道建立的时间(分别为111秒和172秒)较短。模拟组偏离困难气道协会算法的中位次数为0,而非模拟组为1。这项小型研究表明,高仿真模拟可缩短麻醉实习医生在后续模拟CICO情况下的决策时间。这一观察结果值得在更大规模的前瞻性试验中进行后续研究。