Oh Jiwon, Seigo Michaela, Saidha Shiv, Sotirchos Elias, Zackowski Kathy, Chen Min, Prince Jerry, Diener-West Marie, Calabresi Peter A, Reich Daniel S
Department of Neurology, Johns Hopkins University.
Department of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, Johns Hopkins University.
J Neuroimaging. 2014 Nov-Dec;24(6):577-584. doi: 10.1111/jon.12097. Epub 2014 Mar 5.
Spinal cord (SC) pathology is common in multiple sclerosis (MS), and measures of SC-atrophy are increasingly utilized. Normalization reduces biological variation of structural measurements unrelated to disease, but optimal parameters for SC volume (SCV)-normalization remain unclear. Using a variety of normalization factors and clinical measures, we assessed the effect of SCV normalization on detecting group differences and clarifying clinical-radiological correlations in MS.
3T cervical SC-MRI was performed in 133 MS cases and 11 healthy controls (HC). Clinical assessment included expanded disability status scale (EDSS), MS functional composite (MSFC), quantitative hip-flexion strength ("strength"), and vibration sensation threshold ("vibration"). SCV between C3 and C4 was measured and normalized individually by subject height, SC-length, and intracranial volume (ICV).
There were group differences in raw-SCV and after normalization by height and length (MS vs. HC; progressive vs. relapsing MS-subtypes, P < .05). There were correlations between clinical measures and raw-SCV (EDSS:r = -.20; MSFC:r = .16; strength:r = .35; vibration:r = -.19). Correlations consistently strengthened with normalization by length (EDSS:r = -.43; MSFC:r = .33; strength:r = .38; vibration:r = -.40), and height (EDSS:r = -.26; MSFC:r = .28; strength:r = .22; vibration:r = -.29), but diminished with normalization by ICV (EDSS:r = -.23; MSFC:r = -.10; strength:r = .23; vibration:r = -.35). In relapsing MS, normalization by length allowed statistical detection of correlations that were not apparent with raw-SCV.
SCV-normalization by length improves the ability to detect group differences, strengthens clinical-radiological correlations, and is particularly relevant in settings of subtle disease-related SC-atrophy in MS. SCV-normalization by length may enhance the clinical utility of measures of SC-atrophy.
脊髓(SC)病理改变在多发性硬化症(MS)中很常见,脊髓萎缩的测量方法也越来越多地被采用。标准化可减少与疾病无关的结构测量的生物学变异,但脊髓体积(SCV)标准化的最佳参数仍不明确。我们使用多种标准化因子和临床测量方法,评估了SCV标准化对检测MS组间差异及阐明临床-放射学相关性的影响。
对133例MS患者和11名健康对照者(HC)进行了3T颈椎脊髓MRI检查。临床评估包括扩展残疾状态量表(EDSS)、MS功能综合评分(MSFC)、定量髋部屈曲力量(“力量”)和振动感觉阈值(“振动”)。测量了C3和C4之间的SCV,并分别根据受试者身高、脊髓长度和颅内体积(ICV)进行标准化。
原始SCV以及经身高和长度标准化后的SCV存在组间差异(MS与HC;进展型与复发型MS亚型,P <.05)。临床测量与原始SCV之间存在相关性(EDSS:r = -0.20;MSFC:r = 0.16;力量:r = 0.35;振动:r = -0.19)。经长度标准化(EDSS:r = -0.43;MSFC:r = 0.33;力量:r = 0.38;振动:r = -0.40)和身高标准化(EDSS:r = -0.26;MSFC:r = 0.28;力量:r = 0.22;振动:r = -0.29)后,相关性持续增强,但经ICV标准化后相关性减弱(EDSS:r = -0.23;MSFC:r = -0.10;力量:r = 0.23;振动:r = -0.35)。在复发型MS中,经长度标准化能够对原始SCV时不明显的相关性进行统计学检测。
经长度标准化的SCV提高了检测组间差异的能力,加强了临床-放射学相关性,并且在MS中与疾病相关的脊髓细微萎缩情况下尤为相关。经长度标准化的SCV可能会增强脊髓萎缩测量的临床实用性。