MacLean Evan L, Krupenye Christopher, Hare Brian
Department of Evolutionary Anthropology, Duke University.
J Comp Psychol. 2014 Aug;128(3):285-97. doi: 10.1037/a0035742. Epub 2014 Mar 10.
In a series of four experiments we investigated whether dogs use information about a human's visual perspective when responding to pointing gestures. While there is evidence that dogs may know what humans can and cannot see, and that they flexibly use human communicative gestures, it is unknown if they can integrate these two skills. In Experiment 1 we first determined that dogs were capable of using basic information about a human's body orientation (indicative of her visual perspective) in a point following context. Subjects were familiarized with experimenters who either faced the dog and accurately indicated the location of hidden food, or faced away from the dog and (falsely) indicated the unbaited container. In test trials these cues were pitted against one another and dogs tended to follow the gesture from the individual who faced them while pointing. In Experiments 2-4 the experimenter pointed ambiguously toward two possible locations where food could be hidden. On test trials a visual barrier occluded the pointer's view of one container, while dogs could always see both containers. We predicted that if dogs could take the pointer's visual perspective they should search in the only container visible to the pointer. This hypothesis was supported only in Experiment 2. We conclude that while dogs are skilled both at following human gestures, and exploiting information about others' visual perspectives, they may not integrate these skills in the manner characteristic of human children.
在一系列四项实验中,我们研究了狗在对指示性手势做出反应时是否会利用有关人类视觉视角的信息。虽然有证据表明狗可能知道人类能看到什么和看不到什么,并且它们能灵活运用人类的交流手势,但它们是否能将这两种技能结合起来尚不清楚。在实验1中,我们首先确定狗在跟随指示的情境中能够利用有关人类身体朝向(表明其视觉视角)的基本信息。实验对象熟悉了这样的实验者:一种是面对狗并准确指出隐藏食物位置的,另一种是背向狗并(错误地)指向没有诱饵的容器的。在测试试验中,将这些线索相互较量,狗往往会跟随指向它们的人的手势。在实验2至4中,实验者模糊地指向食物可能隐藏的两个位置。在测试试验中,一个视觉障碍物挡住了指示者对一个容器的视线,而狗总能看到两个容器。我们预测,如果狗能够采取指示者的视觉视角,它们应该会在指示者唯一能看到的容器中寻找。只有在实验2中这一假设得到了支持。我们得出结论,虽然狗在跟随人类手势和利用有关他人视觉视角的信息方面都很熟练,但它们可能不会像人类儿童那样将这些技能结合起来。