Assist Technol. 2013 Winter;25(4):222-9. doi: 10.1080/10400435.2013.768719.
We present results from a mixed methods study of screen reader use and switching behavior among people with vision impairments in India. We examine loyalty and experimentation with screen readers and find that the main drivers of adoption for early users differ significantly from the factors that drive continued use by advanced users. We discuss the factor that emerges as one of the strongest stated drivers of early adoption, text-to-speech "voice" quality, particularly a "human-sounding voice" as one of the key features differentiating free/open source products from more expensive proprietary products. While the initial preferences are driven by voice quality, application support becomes more important over time as users speed up their sound settings and become more comfortable with the resultant non-human-sounding speech. We discuss these findings from two theoretical perspectives--first, through the application of the economics of behavior switching, and second, vis-à-vis novice and expert approaches toward new product adoption. We argue that these findings further our understanding of initial user comfort related to assistive technology adoption, and the impact of early technology choices on long-term technology switching behavior.
我们呈现了一项混合方法研究的结果,该研究调查了印度视力障碍者使用屏幕阅读器和切换行为。我们考察了对屏幕阅读器的忠诚度和实验情况,发现早期用户采用的主要驱动因素与推动高级用户持续使用的因素有很大的不同。我们讨论了一个被认为是早期采用的最强驱动因素之一的因素,即文本到语音的“语音”质量,特别是“听起来像人”的语音,这是免费/开源产品与更昂贵的专有产品的关键区别之一。虽然最初的偏好是由语音质量驱动的,但随着用户加快声音设置速度并对非人性化的语音变得更加舒适,应用程序支持变得越来越重要。我们从两个理论视角来讨论这些发现——首先,通过应用行为切换的经济学,其次,从新手和专家对新产品采用的角度来看。我们认为,这些发现进一步加深了我们对与辅助技术采用相关的初始用户舒适度的理解,以及早期技术选择对长期技术切换行为的影响。