University of Virginia , 210 Emmett Street South, Charlottesville, VA, USA.
Westtown School , Westtown, PA, USA.
J Sports Sci Med. 2004 Dec 1;3(4):220-5. eCollection 2004 Dec.
To identify if lower extremity malalignments were associated with increased propensity of a history of anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) ruptures in males and females using a case control design. Twenty subjects (10 males, 10 females) had a history of ACL injury and twenty (10 males, 10 females) had no history of ACL injury. Subjects were assessed for navicular drop, quadriceps angle, pelvic tilt, hip internal and external rotation range of motion, and true and apparent leg length discrepancies. Statistical analysis was performed to identify differences in these measures in regard to injury history and gender, and to identify if any of these measures were predictive of ACL injury history. Increased navicular drop and anterior pelvic tilt were found to be statistically significant predictors of ACL injury history regardless of gender. Limbs that had previously suffered ACL ruptures were found to have increased navicular drop and anterior pelvic tilt compared to uninjured limbs. Based on the results of this retrospective study, the lower extremity malalignments examined do not appear to predispose females to tearing their ACLs more than males. Key PointsHyperpronation and greater anterior pelvic tilt were the two malalignments most associated with history of ACL injury.Females had larger quadriceps angles than males, but this measure was not significantly related to ACL injury history.Not all structural differences between genders help explain the increased risk of ACL injuries in female athletes.
为了确定下肢对线不良是否与男性和女性前交叉韧带(ACL)撕裂史的发生倾向有关,我们采用病例对照设计。20 名受试者(10 名男性,10 名女性)有 ACL 损伤史,20 名(10 名男性,10 名女性)无 ACL 损伤史。对受试者进行了足舟骨下降、股四头肌角度、骨盆倾斜、髋关节内旋和外旋活动范围以及真性和假性肢体长度差异的评估。进行了统计学分析,以确定这些测量值在损伤史和性别方面的差异,并确定这些测量值中是否有任何一个可以预测 ACL 损伤史。无论性别如何,足舟骨下降和骨盆前倾增加都被发现是 ACL 损伤史的统计学显著预测因素。与未受伤的肢体相比,先前遭受 ACL 撕裂的肢体的足舟骨下降和骨盆前倾更大。基于这项回顾性研究的结果,所检查的下肢对线不良似乎不会使女性比男性更容易撕裂 ACL。关键点:过度旋前和更大的骨盆前倾是与 ACL 损伤史最相关的两个对线不良。女性的股四头肌角度大于男性,但这一测量值与 ACL 损伤史无显著相关性。并非所有性别之间的结构差异都有助于解释女性运动员 ACL 损伤风险增加。