Fernández Ibieta M, Sánchez Morote J M, Martínez Castaño I, Reyes Ríos P, Cabrejos Perotti K, Rojas Ticona J, Ruiz Pruneda R, Aranda García M J, Roqués Serradilla J L, Trujillo Ascanio A, Hernández Bermejo J P, Ruiz Jiménez J I
Cir Pediatr. 2013 Oct;26(4):183-8.
Long term results of different surgical techniques in Hirschsprung's Disease (HD) are contradictory. There are still no long term large or multicentric reports about functional results of De la Torre technique. We have studied the mid term functional results of the patients operated on Duhamel (D) and De la Torre (dlT) pull-through procedures.
We collected data from medical records and telephone interviews of the HD patients operated in our unit in the last 16 years.
38 patients were found. Ages ranged from 1.5 to 21 years. Mean age was 7.7 years. Median follow up was 5.9 years. 33 (86.8%) had rectosigmoid disease and 5 (13.2%) had long segment disease. D procedure was performed in 17 (44.7%), Soave in 1 (2.6%), Duhamel-Lester-Martin in 4 (10.5%) and dlT pull-through in 16(42%). In the last visit record, 12 (31.6%), had constipation, and fecal leaks were noted in 11 (33.3%) of the 33 patients > or = 4 years old.. 10 patients (29.4% of the > or = 4 years old group) referred encopresis along the follow-up. Patients from the D group referred higher rates of constipation than those in the dlT group (53.3% vs 20% p=0.048). dlT patients referred more frequency of leaks (46,1% vs 13,3%, p=0,05) Children with very short resections (< or = 10 cm) were more prone to constipation than children with longer resections (66,6% vs 17.4% p=0.007), and less prone to present leaks (12.5% vs 47.3% p=0.08). Encopresis was similar in all groups.
Both techniques show similar functional results in the mid term, although children in the D group were more prone to constipation and those in the dlT group presented more fecal leaks. All patients with EH need long follow-ups.
不同手术技术治疗先天性巨结肠症(HD)的长期结果存在矛盾。目前仍缺乏关于德拉托雷技术功能结果的长期大型或多中心报告。我们研究了接受杜哈梅尔(D)和德拉托雷(dlT)拖出术患者的中期功能结果。
我们收集了过去16年在我们科室接受手术的HD患者的病历数据和电话访谈资料。
共找到38例患者。年龄范围为1.5至21岁。平均年龄为7.7岁。中位随访时间为5.9年。33例(86.8%)患有直肠乙状结肠疾病,5例(13.2%)患有长段疾病。17例(44.7%)接受了D手术,1例(2.6%)接受了索阿韦手术,4例(10.5%)接受了杜哈梅尔 - 莱斯特 - 马丁手术,16例(42%)接受了dlT拖出术。在最后一次随访记录中,12例(31.6%)有便秘,在33例年龄≥4岁的患者中,11例(33.3%)有粪便泄漏。10例患者(≥4岁组的29.4%)在随访期间出现遗粪症。D组患者便秘发生率高于dlT组(53.3%对20%,p = 0.048)。dlT组患者泄漏频率更高(46.1%对13.3%,p = 0.05)。切除范围非常短(≤10 cm)的儿童比切除范围较长的儿童更容易便秘(66.6%对17.4%,p = 0.007),且出现泄漏的可能性较小(12.5%对47.3%,p = 0.08)。各组遗粪症情况相似。
两种技术在中期显示出相似的功能结果,尽管D组儿童更容易便秘,而dlT组儿童粪便泄漏更多。所有先天性巨结肠症患者都需要长期随访。