Quillian Lincoln
Northwestern University.
Am Sociol Rev. 2012 Jun 1;77(3):354-379. doi: 10.1177/0003122412447793.
A key argument of Massey and Denton's (1993) is that racial residential segregation and non-white group poverty rates combine interactively to produce spatially concentrated poverty. Despite a compelling theoretical rationale, the empirical tests of this proposition have been negative or mixed. This paper develops a formal decomposition model that expands the Massey model of how segregation, group poverty rates, and other spatial conditions combine to form concentrated poverty. The revised decomposition model allows for income effects on cross-race neighborhood residence and interactive combinations of multiple spatial conditions in the formation of concentrated poverty. Applying the model to data reveals that racial segregation and income segregation within race contribute importantly to poverty concentration, as Massey argued, but that almost equally important for poverty concentration is the disproportionate poverty of the non-group neighbors of blacks and Hispanics. The missing interaction Massey expected in empirical tests can be found with proper accounting for the factors in the expanded model. "Because of racial segregation, a significant share of black America is condemned to experience a social environment where poverty and joblessness are the norm, where a majority of children are born out of wedlock, where most families are on welfare, where educational failure prevails, and where social and physical deterioration abound. Through prolonged exposure to such an environment, black chances for social and economic success are drastically reduced."--Douglas Massey and Nancy Denton, , p. 2.
梅西和丹顿(1993年)的一个关键论点是,种族居住隔离与非白人族群的贫困率相互作用,导致贫困在空间上集中。尽管有令人信服的理论依据,但对这一命题的实证检验结果却是否定的或好坏参半。本文构建了一个正式的分解模型,扩展了梅西关于隔离、族群贫困率和其他空间条件如何相互作用形成集中贫困的模型。修订后的分解模型考虑了收入对跨种族邻里居住的影响以及多种空间条件在集中贫困形成过程中的相互作用组合。将该模型应用于数据后发现,正如梅西所主张的,种族隔离和种族内部的收入隔离对贫困集中有重要影响,但对贫困集中几乎同样重要的是黑人和西班牙裔非族群邻居中不成比例的贫困现象。在对扩展模型中的因素进行适当考量后,就能发现梅西在实证检验中所期望的那种缺失的相互作用。“由于种族隔离,相当一部分美国黑人注定要经历一种社会环境,在这种环境中,贫困和失业是常态,大多数儿童是非婚生育,大多数家庭依赖福利救济,教育失败普遍存在,社会和物质环境恶化随处可见。长期处于这样的环境中,黑人获得社会和经济成功的机会将大幅减少。”——道格拉斯·梅西和南希·丹顿,第2页。