Swint J M, Greenberg F
University of Texas School of Public Health, Houston 77225.
Am J Med Genet. 1988 Sep;31(1):231-45. doi: 10.1002/ajmg.1320310130.
The economic consequences of using an index of maternal age and maternal serum alpha-fetoprotein (MSAFP) screening to indicate risk of Down syndrome (DS) are examined. If DS screening indicated solely by a given maternal age is economically justifiable, then amniocentesis indicated by a DS risk equivalent to that maternal age cutoff, but based on an index of maternal age (for ages below the cutoff) and low MSAFP results, is also economically justifiable. It is concluded that the extant use of MSAFP screening for DS is a move toward the cost-effective use of scarce resources that can be made available with coordinated planning. However, increased professional and public awareness may result in significant increases in aggregate demand for these services. While MSAFP screening for DS is economically justifiable, there exists some potential for bottlenecks at the aggregate level, and these should be considered in conjunction with recommendations that the technology be adopted on a widespread basis.
本文探讨了使用产妇年龄指数和母血清甲胎蛋白(MSAFP)筛查来评估唐氏综合征(DS)风险的经济后果。如果仅根据特定产妇年龄进行的DS筛查在经济上是合理的,那么基于与该产妇年龄临界值相当的DS风险(但基于产妇年龄指数(适用于低于临界值的年龄)和低MSAFP结果)所进行的羊膜穿刺术在经济上也是合理的。研究得出结论,目前使用MSAFP筛查DS是朝着有效利用稀缺资源迈出的一步,通过协调规划可以实现资源的有效利用。然而,专业人员和公众意识的提高可能会导致对这些服务的总需求大幅增加。虽然MSAFP筛查DS在经济上是合理的,但在总体层面存在一些潜在的瓶颈,在建议广泛采用该技术时应考虑到这些瓶颈。