Zanoni A, Rice T W, Lopez R, Birgisson S, Shay S S, Thota P N, Baker M E, Raymond D P, Blackstone E H
Department of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery, Heart and Vascular Institute, Cleveland, Ohio, USA.
Dis Esophagus. 2015 May-Jun;28(4):336-44. doi: 10.1111/dote.12212. Epub 2014 Mar 20.
Relationships of timed barium esophagram (TBE) findings to achalasia types defined by high-resolution manometry (HRM) have not been elucidated. Therefore, we correlated preoperative TBE and HRM measurements in achalasia types and related these to patient symptoms and prior treatments. From 2006 to 2013, 248 achalasia patients underwent TBE and HRM before Heller myotomy. TBE height and width were recorded at 1 and 5 minutes; HRM measured lower esophageal sphincter mean basal pressure, integrated relaxation pressure (IRP), and mean esophageal body contraction amplitude. Achalasia was classified into types I (25%), II (65%), and III (9.7%). TBE height at 5 minutes was higher for I (median 8 cm; interquartile range 6-12) and II (8 cm; 8-11) than for III (1 cm; 0-7). TBE width at 5 minutes was widest (3 cm; 2-4), narrower in II (2 cm; 2-3), and narrowest in I (1 cm; 0-2), P < 0.001. Volume remaining at 1 and 5 minutes was lower in III (1 m(2) ; 0-16) than I (42 m(2) ; 17-106) and II (39 m(2) ; 15-60), highlighting poorer emptying of I and II. Increasing TBE width correlated with deteriorating morphology and function from III to II to I. Symptoms poorly correlated with TBE and HRM. Prior treatment was associated with less regurgitation, faster emptying, and lower IRP. Although TBE and HRM are correlated in many respects, the wide range of their measurements observed in this study reveals a spectrum of morphology and dysfunction in achalasia that is best characterized by the combination of these studies.
定时钡餐食管造影(TBE)检查结果与高分辨率测压法(HRM)所定义的贲门失弛缓症类型之间的关系尚未阐明。因此,我们将贲门失弛缓症各类型的术前TBE和HRM测量结果进行了关联,并将这些结果与患者症状及既往治疗情况相关联。2006年至2013年期间,248例贲门失弛缓症患者在接受海勒肌切开术之前接受了TBE和HRM检查。记录了1分钟和5分钟时TBE的高度和宽度;HRM测量了食管下括约肌平均基础压力、综合松弛压力(IRP)以及食管体部平均收缩幅度。贲门失弛缓症分为I型(25%)、II型(65%)和III型(9.7%)。I型(中位数8厘米;四分位间距6 - 12)和II型(8厘米;8 - 11)在5分钟时的TBE高度高于III型(1厘米;0 - 7)。III型在5分钟时的TBE宽度最宽(3厘米;2 - 4),II型较窄(2厘米;2 - 3),I型最窄(1厘米;0 - 2),P < 0.001。III型在1分钟和5分钟时剩余的容量(1平方米;0 - 16)低于I型(42平方米;17 - 106)和II型(39平方米;15 - 60),这突出表明I型和II型的排空较差。从III型到II型再到I型,TBE宽度增加与形态和功能恶化相关。症状与TBE和HRM的相关性较差。既往治疗与反流减少、排空加快以及IRP降低相关。尽管TBE和HRM在许多方面相关,但本研究中观察到的它们测量值的广泛范围揭示了贲门失弛缓症中一系列的形态和功能障碍,这些最好通过这两项检查的结合来表征。