Langlands Fiona E, Dodwell David, Hanby Andrew M, Horgan Kieran, Millican-Slater Rebecca A, Speirs Valerie, Verghese Eldo T, Smith Laura, Hughes Thomas A
Leeds Institutes of Molecular Medicine, University of Leeds, Leeds, UK.
Mol Cancer. 2014 Mar 28;13:73. doi: 10.1186/1476-4598-13-73.
More than 50% of cancer patients are recommended to receive radiotherapy. Recommendations are based mainly on clinical and pathological factors and not intrinsic tumour radio-sensitivity. Use of radiotherapy according to predictive markers would potentially reduce costly over-treatment, and improve the treatment risk-benefit ratio and cancer outcomes. Tumour expression of the 26S proteasome has been reported to predict radiotherapy response: low expression was associated with higher rates of local recurrence after radiotherapy, suggesting that low proteasome expression and activity was associated with radio-resistance. However, this conclusion is at odds with the emerging use of proteasome inhibitors as radio-sensitizers. Our aim was to further analyse the relevance of 26S proteasome expression, focussing specifically on the PSMD9 subunit, in the largest clinical cohort to date, and to investigate the functional role of PSMD9 in radio-sensitivity in breast cancer cell lines.
We examined expression of PSMD9 using immunohistochemistry in a cohort of 157 breast cancer patients, including 32 cases (20.4%) that subsequently developed local recurrences. The value of expression as a prognostic or radiotherapy predictive marker was tested using Kaplan-Meier and Cox regression analyses. PSMD9 function was examined in breast cancer cell lines MCF7 and MDA-MB-231 using siRNA knock-downs and colony forming assays after irradiation.
Low tumour PSMD9 expression was significantly associated with a reduced incidence of local recurrence in patients receiving adjuvant radiotherapy (univariate log rank p = 0.02; multivariate regression p = 0.009), but not in those treated without radiotherapy, suggesting that low PSMD9 expression was associated with relative tumour radio-sensitivity. In support of this, reduction of PSMD9 expression using siRNA in breast cancer cell lines in vitro sensitized cells to radiotherapy.
We conclude that PSMD9 expression may predict radiotherapy benefit, with low expression indicative of relative radio-sensitivity, the opposite of previous reports relating to 26S proteasome expression. Our conclusion is compatible with use of proteasome inhibitors as radio-sensitizers, and highlights PSMD9 as a potential target for radio-sensitizing drugs.
超过50%的癌症患者被建议接受放射治疗。这些建议主要基于临床和病理因素,而非肿瘤本身的放射敏感性。根据预测标志物使用放射治疗可能会减少代价高昂的过度治疗,并改善治疗的风险效益比和癌症治疗效果。据报道,26S蛋白酶体的肿瘤表达可预测放射治疗反应:低表达与放射治疗后局部复发率较高相关,这表明蛋白酶体低表达和低活性与放射抗性相关。然而,这一结论与蛋白酶体抑制剂作为放射增敏剂的新应用相矛盾。我们的目的是在迄今为止最大的临床队列中进一步分析26S蛋白酶体表达的相关性,特别关注PSMD9亚基,并研究PSMD9在乳腺癌细胞系放射敏感性中的功能作用。
我们使用免疫组织化学方法检测了157例乳腺癌患者队列中PSMD9的表达,其中32例(20.4%)随后发生了局部复发。使用Kaplan-Meier和Cox回归分析来检验该表达作为预后或放射治疗预测标志物的价值。在乳腺癌细胞系MCF7和MDA-MB-231中,使用小干扰RNA(siRNA)敲低并在照射后进行集落形成试验,以检测PSMD9的功能。
肿瘤PSMD9低表达与接受辅助放疗患者的局部复发率降低显著相关(单因素对数秩检验p = 0.02;多因素回归p = 0.009),但在未接受放疗的患者中无此相关性,这表明PSMD9低表达与肿瘤相对放射敏感性相关。体外在乳腺癌细胞系中使用siRNA降低PSMD9表达可使细胞对放射治疗敏感,这支持了上述结论。
我们得出结论,PSMD9表达可能预测放射治疗获益,低表达表明相对放射敏感性,这与先前关于26S蛋白酶体表达的报道相反。我们的结论与蛋白酶体抑制剂作为放射增敏剂的应用相符,并突出了PSMD9作为放射增敏药物潜在靶点的地位。