Pileggi Claudia, Manuti Benedetto, Costantino Rosa, Bianco Aida, Nobile Carmelo G A, Pavia Maria
Department of Health Sciences, University of Catanzaro "Magna Græcia", Catanzaro, Italy.
PLoS One. 2014 Mar 27;9(3):e93064. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0093064. eCollection 2014.
To adapt the Assessing Care of Vulnerable Elders Quality Indicators (ACOVE QIs) for use in Italy, to assess the adherence to these indicators as reported in the medical records of residents in a nursing home (NH), to compare this adherence for general medical and geriatric conditions, and eventually, to identify the relationships between patients' characteristics and reported processes of care.
Two physicians collected the data by reviewing medical records of all NH residents in the previous 5 years, for a period of one year. Patients aged <65 years were excluded. A total of 245 patients were reviewed during the study period. The ACOVE QIs set, developed for NH processes of care, was used to assess the quality of care. Multivariate analysis was performed to identify and to assess the role of patients' characteristics on quality of processes of care by several domains of care in general medical and geriatric conditions.
With the exception of diabetes management, quality of processes of care for general medical conditions approached adequate adherence. Care falls substantially short of acceptable levels for geriatric conditions (pressure ulcers, falls, dementia). On the contrary, the recommended interventions for urinary incontinence were commonly performed. Adherence to indicators varied for the different domains of care and was proven worse for the screening and prevention indicators both for geriatric and general medical conditions. Statistical analysis showed disparities in provision of appropriate processes of care associated with gender, age, co-morbidities, level of function and mobility, length of stay and modality of discharge by NHs.
Adherence to recommended processes of care delivered in NH is inadequate. Substantial work lies ahead for the improvement of care. Efforts should focus particularly on management of geriatric conditions and on preventive healthcare.
调整《脆弱老年人护理质量评估指标》(ACOVE QIs)以用于意大利,评估养老院(NH)居民病历中所报告的对这些指标的依从性,比较一般医疗和老年疾病方面的这种依从性,并最终确定患者特征与所报告的护理过程之间的关系。
两名医生通过回顾前5年所有NH居民的病历,为期一年来收集数据。排除年龄小于65岁的患者。研究期间共审查了245名患者。用于NH护理过程的ACOVE QIs集被用于评估护理质量。进行多变量分析以确定并评估患者特征在一般医疗和老年疾病的几个护理领域中对护理过程质量的作用。
除糖尿病管理外,一般医疗状况的护理过程质量接近充分依从。老年疾病(压疮、跌倒、痴呆)的护理远未达到可接受水平。相反,针对尿失禁的推荐干预措施通常得到执行。不同护理领域对指标的依从性各不相同,并且事实证明,老年和一般医疗状况的筛查及预防指标的依从性更差。统计分析表明,在提供适当护理过程方面存在差异,这与性别、年龄、合并症、功能和活动水平、住院时间以及NH的出院方式有关。
NH中对推荐护理过程的依从性不足。改善护理工作仍任重道远。应特别关注老年疾病的管理和预防性医疗保健。