Departamento de Microbiología y Ecología, Facultad de Medicina y Odontología, Universitat de València, Valencia, Spain.
Instituto Leônidas e Maria Deane - Fiocruz Amazônia, Manaus, Brazil.
PLoS Negl Trop Dis. 2014 Apr 3;8(4):e2782. doi: 10.1371/journal.pntd.0002782. eCollection 2014 Apr.
Chagas disease has historically been hyperendemic in the Bolivian Department of Cochabamba. In the early 2000s, an extensive vector control program was implemented; 1.34 million dwelling inspections were conducted to ascertain infestation (2000-2001/2003-2011), with blanket insecticide spraying in 2003-2005 and subsequent survey-spraying cycles targeting residual infestation foci. Here, we assess the effects of this program on dwelling infestation rates (DIRs).
METHODOLOGY/PRINCIPAL FINDINGS: Program records were used to calculate annual, municipality-level aggregate DIRs (39 municipalities); very high values in 2000-2001 (median: 0.77-0.69) dropped to ∼0.03 from 2004 on. A linear mixed model (with municipality as a random factor) suggested that infestation odds decreased, on average, by ∼28% (95% confidence interval [CI95] 6-44%) with each 10-fold increase in control effort. A second, better-fitting mixed model including year as an ordinal predictor disclosed large DIR reductions in 2001-2003 (odds ratio [OR] 0.11, CI95 0.06-0.19) and 2003-2004 (OR 0.22, CI95 0.14-0.34). Except for a moderate decrease in 2005-2006, no significant changes were detected afterwards. In both models, municipality-level DIRs correlated positively with previous-year DIRs and with the extent of municipal territory originally covered by montane dry forests.
CONCLUSIONS/SIGNIFICANCE: Insecticide-spraying campaigns had very strong, long-lasting effects on DIRs in Cochabamba. However, post-intervention surveys consistently detected infestation in ∼3% of dwellings, underscoring the need for continuous surveillance; higher DIRs were recorded in the capital city and, more generally, in municipalities dominated by montane dry forest--an eco-region where wild Triatoma infestans are widespread. Traditional strategies combining insecticide spraying and longitudinal surveillance are thus confirmed as very effective means for area-wide Chagas disease vector control; they will be particularly beneficial in highly-endemic settings, but should also be implemented or maintained in other parts of Latin America where domestic infestation by triatomines is still commonplace.
查加斯病在玻利维亚科恰班巴省历史上高度流行。在 21 世纪初,实施了一项广泛的病媒控制计划;进行了 134 万次住宅检查以确定感染情况(2000-2001/2003-2011 年),2003-2005 年进行了全面杀虫剂喷洒,随后针对残留感染焦点进行了调查性喷洒周期。在这里,我们评估该计划对住宅感染率(DIR)的影响。
方法/主要发现:使用项目记录计算了年度、市级综合 DIR(39 个城市);2000-2001 年的高值(中位数:0.77-0.69)自 2004 年以来降至约 0.03。线性混合模型(以市为随机因素)表明,感染几率平均下降了约 28%(95%置信区间[CI95]6-44%),每增加 10 倍的控制力度。一个包含年份作为有序预测因子的第二个更好拟合的混合模型显示,2001-2003 年(比值比[OR]0.11,CI950.06-0.19)和 2003-2004 年(OR0.22,CI950.14-0.34)DIR 大幅降低。除 2005-2006 年略有下降外,此后未检测到显著变化。在这两个模型中,市一级的 DIR 与上一年的 DIR 以及受高山干旱森林覆盖的市辖区域的范围呈正相关。
结论/意义:杀虫剂喷洒运动对科恰班巴的 DIR 产生了非常强烈、持久的影响。然而,干预后的调查始终在约 3%的住宅中检测到感染,这突显了持续监测的必要性;首都和更普遍的高山干旱森林为主的城市记录了更高的 DIR-在那里,野生的三锥虫广泛分布。因此,结合杀虫剂喷洒和纵向监测的传统策略被证实是广泛区域内查加斯病病媒控制的非常有效手段;它们在高度流行地区特别有益,但也应在拉丁美洲其他地方实施或维持,在这些地方,三锥虫的家庭感染仍然很常见。