Bartone Paul T
Int J Emerg Ment Health. 2013;15(4):299-305.
In the years since 2005, suicides among U.S. military personnel have risen dramatically, and continue to rise despite significant leadership attention to suicide awareness and prevention. Prevention efforts have proven unsuccessful, perhaps because they have focused on associated factors, rather than the underlying more fundamental contributing ones. Current suicide prevention and education programs in the military address the symptoms, while ignoring the underlying problem. This paper presents a new taxonomy for organizing and thinking about the multitude of factors associated with suicide in the military. We distinguish four sets of factors associated with suicide: (1) Formative factors are the long-term, fundamental causative factors in suicide, contributing to alienation and powerlessness; (2) Background factors are associated with suicide, but are not clearly causative, as for example age and sex; (3) Precipitating factors are the near-term causative factors, acute stressful events that can plunge the individual into sudden despair, such as a broken marriage; (4) Enabling factors are those that facilitate the act of suicide, but are not underlying causes. This includes for example alcohol and drugs, and easy access to weapons. To succeed, efforts to prevent suicide in the military should be directed to the formative factors. A model is presented in which military-specific formative factors are shown to contribute to alienation and powerlessness, key factors that can lead to suicide. Drawing from the hardiness model of resilience, some recommendations are provided for building up the sense of commitment (vs. alienation) and control (vs. powerlessness) in military personnel as a strategy for reducing suicide.
自2005年以来,美国军事人员的自杀率急剧上升,尽管领导层对自杀意识和预防给予了高度关注,但自杀率仍在持续攀升。预防措施已被证明并不成功,这可能是因为它们关注的是相关因素,而非更根本的潜在促成因素。目前军队中的自杀预防和教育项目只解决了表面症状,却忽略了根本问题。本文提出了一种新的分类法,用于梳理和思考与军队自杀相关的众多因素。我们区分了与自杀相关的四类因素:(1)形成性因素是自杀的长期、根本成因,会导致疏离感和无力感;(2)背景因素与自杀相关,但并非明确的成因,例如年龄和性别;(3)促发因素是近期的成因,即能使个体突然陷入绝望的急性应激事件,比如婚姻破裂;(4)促成因素是那些便利自杀行为但并非根本原因的因素。这包括例如酒精和毒品,以及容易获取武器。为取得成功,军队中的自杀预防工作应针对形成性因素。本文提出了一个模型,其中展示了特定于军队的形成性因素会导致疏离感和无力感,而这是可能导致自杀的关键因素。借鉴复原力的坚毅模型,本文提供了一些建议,旨在增强军事人员的使命感(而非疏离感)和掌控感(而非无力感),以此作为减少自杀的一种策略。