Molinari Robert, Bessette Matthew, Raich Annie L, Dettori Joseph R, Molinari Christine
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, University of Rochester Medical Center, Rochester, New York, United States.
Spectrum Research, Inc., Tacoma, Washington, United States.
Evid Based Spine Care J. 2014 Apr;5(1):16-27. doi: 10.1055/s-0034-1366980.
Systematic review.
The purpose of this review is to further define the published literature with respect to vertebral artery (VA) anomaly and injury in patients with degenerative cervical spinal conditions.
In adult patients with cervical spine or degenerative cervical spine disorders receiving cervical spine surgery, what is the incidence of VA injury, and among resulting VA injuries, which treatments result in a successful outcome and what percent are successfully repaired?
A systematic review of pertinent articles published up to April 2013. Studies involving traumatic onset, fracture, infection, deformity or congenital abnormality, instability, inflammatory spinal diseases, or neoplasms were excluded. Two independent reviewers assessed the level of evidence quality using the Grades of Recommendation Assessment, Development and Evaluation criteria; disagreements were resolved by consensus.
From a total of 72 possible citations, the following met our inclusion criteria and formed the basis for this report. Incidence of VA injuries ranged from 0.20 to 1.96%. None of the studies reported using preoperative imaging to identify anomalous or tortuous VA. Primary repair and ligation were the most effective in treating VA injuries.
The incidence of VA injuries in degenerative cervical spinal surgery might be as high as 1.96% and is likely underreported. Direct surgical repair is the most effective treatment option. The most important preventative technique for VA injuries is preoperative magnetic resonance imaging or computed tomography angiographic imaging to detect VA anomalies. The overall strength of evidence for the conclusions is low.
系统评价。
本评价的目的是进一步明确已发表文献中关于退行性颈椎疾病患者椎动脉(VA)异常和损伤的情况。
在接受颈椎手术的成年颈椎或退行性颈椎疾病患者中,VA损伤的发生率是多少,在由此导致的VA损伤中,哪些治疗方法能取得成功的结果,成功修复的比例是多少?
对截至2013年4月发表的相关文章进行系统评价。排除涉及创伤性发病、骨折、感染、畸形或先天性异常、不稳定、炎性脊柱疾病或肿瘤的研究。两名独立评审员使用推荐分级评估、制定和评价标准评估证据质量水平;分歧通过协商一致解决。
在总共72篇可能的引文中,以下符合我们的纳入标准并构成本报告的基础。VA损伤的发生率在0.20%至1.96%之间。没有研究报告使用术前影像学检查来识别异常或迂曲的VA。一期修复和结扎在治疗VA损伤方面最有效。
退行性颈椎手术中VA损伤的发生率可能高达1.96%,且可能报告不足。直接手术修复是最有效的治疗选择。预防VA损伤最重要的技术是术前磁共振成像或计算机断层血管造影成像以检测VA异常。结论的总体证据强度较低。