Plamadeala Victoria, Huang Shuguang, McCreary Suzanne M, Reitze Nicholas J, Ewing Amy L, Gabrin Michael J, Bennett Ana E, Mulligan Jude M, Wilson Claire L, Wang Dakun
*Precision Therapeutics, Pittsburgh, PA †Cleveland Clinic, Cleveland, OH ‡Almac Diagnostics, Craigavon, United Kingdom.
Appl Immunohistochem Mol Morphol. 2014 Apr;22(4):308-16. doi: 10.1097/PDM.0000000000000031.
A formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded tissue-based prognostic assay to assess the risk for recurrence in stage II colon cancer has recently been clinically validated. This study describes the analytical performance and quality control measures of the assay. The reportable range was determined to be [-1.129, 1.414] in risk score units. The accuracy was evaluated with a split sample comparison within the production lab and between the production lab and a reference lab. The concordance between the replicates within the production lab was 79% (95% confidence interval, 64%-91%). There was no evidence of bias, and the concordance was 78% (95% confidence interval, 61%-90%) between the labs. The lab-to-lab concordance was further evaluated by simulating risk scores from the full reportable range. The simulation suggested a higher concordance. The sensitivity study demonstrated that the percentage of tumor tissue did not impact the risk score and that RNA concentration of 9.5 ng/μL was a conservative determination of the analyte lower limit of quantification. From the precision study, the repeatability and reproducibility estimates were 0.1267 and 0.0548 in risk score units, respectively. Furthermore, multifaceted quality control measures were implemented, such as proper tissue processing steps, high-risk and low-risk controls, nontemplate control, and a gene expression-based classifier to evaluate the cDNA amplification kit, a key reagent in the assay. In conclusion, this study demonstrates the strong analytical performance of the assay and further supports its use as an objective standardized prognostic test for stage II colon cancer.
一种用于评估II期结肠癌复发风险的基于福尔马林固定石蜡包埋组织的预后检测方法最近已通过临床验证。本研究描述了该检测方法的分析性能和质量控制措施。风险评分单位的报告范围确定为[-1.129, 1.414]。通过在生产实验室内部以及生产实验室与参考实验室之间进行分割样本比较来评估准确性。生产实验室内重复检测结果的一致性为79%(95%置信区间,64%-91%)。没有偏差证据,实验室之间的一致性为78%(95%置信区间,61%-90%)。通过模拟整个报告范围内的风险评分进一步评估实验室间的一致性。模拟结果显示一致性更高。敏感性研究表明肿瘤组织的百分比不影响风险评分,9.5 ng/μL的RNA浓度是分析物定量下限的保守测定值。从精密度研究来看,风险评分单位的重复性和再现性估计值分别为0.1267和0.0548。此外,还实施了多方面的质量控制措施,如适当的组织处理步骤、高风险和低风险对照、无模板对照,以及用于评估该检测方法关键试剂cDNA扩增试剂盒的基于基因表达的分类器。总之,本研究证明了该检测方法强大的分析性能,并进一步支持将其用作II期结肠癌的客观标准化预后检测方法。