Huang Shuguang, Reitze Nicholas J, Ewing Amy L, McCreary Suzanne, Uihlein Arlette H, Brower Stacey L, Wang Dakun, Wang Tianhua, Gabrin Michael J, Keating Katherine E, Mulligan Jude, Wilson Claire, Davison Timothy, McKenzie Stuart, Tsao Ming-Sound, Shepherd Frances A, Plamadeala Victoria
Helomics Corporation, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.
Almac Diagnostics Ltd., Craigavon, Northern Ireland, United Kingdom.
J Mol Diagn. 2015 Jul;17(4):438-45. doi: 10.1016/j.jmoldx.2015.03.005. Epub 2015 May 8.
A 15-gene prognostic signature for early-stage, completely resected, non-small-cell lung carcinoma, (which distinguishes between patients with good and poor prognoses) was clinically validated in prior studies. To achieve operational efficiencies, this study was designed to evaluate the assay's performance in RNA-stabilized tissue as an alternative to the fresh-frozen tissue format originally used to develop the assay. The percent concordance between matched tissue formats was 84% (95% Wilson CI, 70%-92%), a level of agreement comparable to the inherent reproducibility of the assay observed within biological replicates of fresh-frozen tissue. Furthermore, the analytical performance of the assay using the RNA-stabilized tissue format was evaluated. When compared to an accredited reference laboratory, the clinical laboratory achieved a concordance of 94% (95% Wilson CI, 81%-98%), and there was no evidence of bias between the laboratories. The lower limit of quantitation for the target RNA concentration was confirmed to be, at most, 12.5 ng/μL. The assay reportable range defined in terms of risk score units was determined to be -4.295 to 4.210. In a large-scale precision study, the assay showed high reproducibility and repeatability. When subjected to a maximal amount of genomic DNA, a potential contaminant, the assay still produced the expected results. The 15-gene signature was confirmed to produce reliable results and, thus, is suitable for its intended use.
一种用于早期、完全切除的非小细胞肺癌的15基因预后特征(可区分预后良好和不良的患者)在先前的研究中得到了临床验证。为了提高操作效率,本研究旨在评估该检测方法在RNA稳定组织中的性能,以替代最初用于开发该检测方法的新鲜冷冻组织形式。匹配组织形式之间的一致性百分比为84%(95%威尔逊置信区间,70%-92%),这一一致水平与在新鲜冷冻组织的生物重复样本中观察到的该检测方法的固有可重复性相当。此外,还评估了使用RNA稳定组织形式的检测方法的分析性能。与一家认可的参考实验室相比,临床实验室的一致性为94%(95%威尔逊置信区间,81%-98%),且各实验室之间没有偏差迹象。目标RNA浓度的定量下限经确认最高为12.5 ng/μL。以风险评分单位定义的检测报告范围确定为-4.295至4.210。在一项大规模的精密度研究中,该检测方法显示出高重现性和重复性。当受到最大量的潜在污染物基因组DNA影响时,该检测方法仍能产生预期结果。15基因特征被证实能产生可靠结果,因此适用于其预期用途。