Crippling upper back pain after whiplash and other motor vehicle collisions caused by thoracic disc herniations: report of 10 cases.

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective analysis of a prospectively collected database of thoracoscopic microdiscectomies performed at the Maastricht University Medical Center.

OBJECTIVE

Many victims of a motor vehicle collision (MVC) report crippling upper back pain resistant to conservative treatment. Although this pain is often regarded as nonspecific or related to a whiplash type of cervical spine injury, this study demonstrates it may be caused by a thoracic disc herniation.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Recent literature on bodily pain after whiplash and other MVCs has shown that most patients rather than pain confined to the posterior neck area (0.4%) report pain in multiple body areas, the most frequently affected region being the posterior trunk region, including the posterior neck, posterior shoulder, upper back, lumbar, and buttock areas. Although several patterns determining most variance in pain localization in these patients have been identified, different pathoanatomical and pathophysiological substrates underlying these patterns have not been identified. However, a high incidence of posterior shoulder pain (75%) and upper back pain (66%) is striking.

METHODS

In a series of 326 thoracoscopic microdiscectomies for one or more symptomatic TDHs, we identified 10 patients whose symptoms had started after an MVC. We analyzed their clinical and radiological presentation, intraoperative findings, and postoperative outcome.

RESULTS

All patients (7 females, 3 males; age, 26-58 yr, including 4 with typical whiplash complaints) had reported substantial improvement of their complaints except for their upper back pain. Most hernias were small or medium sized (n = 8), at the apex of the kyphotic curvature (n = 6), and to some extent calcified (n = 7). One year postoperatively, results were excellent in 7, good in 2, and poor in 1.

CONCLUSION

Crippling upper back pain after MVCs may be caused by a (previously asymptomatic) thoracic disc herniation. Although the exact pathophysiological mechanism has not been elucidated, results after thoracoscopic microdiscectomy are quite encouraging.