Zhao Rui, Wu Jun-Qing, Li Yu-Yan, Zhou Ying, Ji Hong-Lei, Li Yi-Ran
Shanghai Institute of Planned Parenthood Research/WHO Collaborating Center on Human Research, Shanghai 200032, China.
BMC Public Health. 2014 Apr 14;14:354. doi: 10.1186/1471-2458-14-354.
To evaluate and compare the effectiveness of the combined regimen (consisting of condoms and emergency contraception pills (ECP)) and using condoms only for the purpose of preventing pregnancy.
One-thousand-five-hundred-and-sixty-two (1,562) couples as volunteers enrolled at nine centers in Shanghai. Eight-hundred-and-twelve (812) were randomized to use male condoms and ECP (i.e., Levonorgestrel) as a back-up to condoms (the intervention group) and 750 to use male condoms only(the control group), according to their working unit. Participants were visited at admission and at the end of 1, 3, 6, 9, and 12 months. The cumulative life table rates were calculated for pregnancy and other reasons for discontinuation.
The gross cumulative life table rates showed that the cumulative discontinuation rates for all reasons during the year of follow-up in the condoms plus emergency contraception group and the condoms only group were 7.76 ± 0.94 and 6.61 ± 0.91, respectively, per 100 women (χ2 = 0.41, p = 0.5227). The cumulative gross pregnancy rate of the condoms plus emergency contraception group and the condoms only group were 2.17 ± 0.52 and 1.25 ± 0.41, respectively, per 100 women (χ2 = 1.93, p = 0.1645). The Pearl Index in the condoms plus emergency contraception group and the condoms only group were 2.21% and 1.26%, respectively.
Male condoms remain a highly effective contraceptive method for a period of one year while consistently and correctly used. In addition, the lowest pregnancy rate followed from perfect use condom.
评估并比较联合方案(由避孕套和紧急避孕药组成)与仅使用避孕套预防妊娠的有效性。
1562对夫妇作为志愿者在上海的9个中心招募。根据工作单位,812对夫妇被随机分配使用男用避孕套并将紧急避孕药(即左炔诺孕酮)作为避孕套的备用措施(干预组),750对夫妇仅使用男用避孕套(对照组)。在入组时以及1、3、6、9和12个月结束时对参与者进行访视。计算妊娠和其他停用原因的累积生命表率。
总累积生命表率显示,在随访的一年中,避孕套加紧急避孕组和仅使用避孕套组每100名女性的所有原因累积停用率分别为7.76±0.94和6.61±0.91(χ² = 0.41,p = 0.5227)。避孕套加紧急避孕组和仅使用避孕套组每100名女性的累积总妊娠率分别为2.17±0.52和1.25±0.41(χ² = 1.93,p = 0.1645)。避孕套加紧急避孕组和仅使用避孕套组的Pearl指数分别为2.21%和1.26%。
男用避孕套在持续正确使用的情况下,一年内仍是一种高效的避孕方法。此外,完美使用避孕套的妊娠率最低。