Białek Andrzej, Pertkiewicz Jan, Karpińska Katarzyna, Marlicz Wojciech, Bielicki Dariusz, Starzyńska Teresa
Departments of aGastroenterology bCell Pathology, Pomeranian Medical University, Szczecin cEndotherapy Ltd, Warsaw, Poland.
Eur J Gastroenterol Hepatol. 2014 Jun;26(6):607-15. doi: 10.1097/MEG.0000000000000079.
Endoscopic submucosal dissection (ESD) has a high curative resection rate for gastrointestinal mucosal lesions, but is not used widely in Europe because of a high complication rate and a long learning curve. This study analyzed the ESD learning curve at a single European treatment center.
ESD and hybrid-ESD (hESD) procedures were used to treat large colonic lesions that could not be resected in one piece by other endoscopic methods. Procedure duration and speed, and en-bloc, complete (R0) resection, and complication rates were analyzed.
Fifty-three patients underwent ESD (37 pure ESD, 16 hESD), most with rectal lesions (n=34, 64.2%). The mean lesion diameter was 3.7 ± 1.1 cm2 (range 2.0-7.0 cm), the median procedure duration was 70.0 min [interquartile range (IQR) 31.0-113.0 min], and the median treatment speed was 0.086 cm2/min (IQR 0.055-0.152). En-bloc and R0 resection rates were 86.5% (32/37) and 81.1% (30/37), respectively. Procedure speed increased significantly after about 25 cases (P=0.0313). The median hESD procedure treatment speed was 0.159 cm/min (n=16, IQR 0.094-0.193), which was better than with classical ESD (P=0.04). The hESD en-bloc and R0 resection rates were comparable to those of classical ESD (P>0.05). The only complication was bleeding, 5.7% (3/53); no perforation occurred. Recurrence was detected during follow-up (median 30.0 months, IQR 12-48) in one patient (1.7%).
ESD is useful and safe for resection of large colorectal polyps, and procedure speed increased considerably after 25 procedures. hESD was faster than ESD, with a high therapeutic resection rate.
内镜粘膜下剥离术(ESD)对胃肠道粘膜病变具有较高的根治性切除率,但由于并发症发生率高和学习曲线长,在欧洲尚未广泛应用。本研究分析了欧洲一家治疗中心的ESD学习曲线。
采用ESD和杂交ESD(hESD)手术治疗其他内镜方法无法完整切除的大肠巨大病变。分析手术时间、速度、整块切除、完整(R0)切除及并发症发生率。
53例患者接受了ESD(37例单纯ESD,16例hESD),大多数为直肠病变(n = 34,64.2%)。病变平均直径为3.7±1.1 cm²(范围2.0 - 7.0 cm),中位手术时间为70.0分钟[四分位间距(IQR)31.0 - 113.0分钟],中位治疗速度为0.086 cm²/分钟(IQR 0.055 - 0.152)。整块切除率和R0切除率分别为86.5%(32/37)和81.1%(30/37)。约25例手术后手术速度显著提高(P = 0.0313)。hESD手术的中位治疗速度为0.159 cm/分钟(n = 16,IQR 0.094 - 0.193),优于传统ESD(P = 0.04)。hESD的整块切除率和R0切除率与传统ESD相当(P>0.05)。唯一的并发症是出血,发生率为5.7%(3/53);未发生穿孔。随访期间(中位时间30.0个月,IQR 12 - 48)发现1例患者(1.7%)复发。
ESD对于大肠巨大息肉的切除是有效且安全的,25例手术后手术速度显著提高。hESD比ESD更快,治疗切除率高。