Tiong William H C, O'Shaughnessy Michael, O'Sullivan Sean T
Department of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, Cork University Hospital, Cork, Ireland.
Clin Pract. 2011 Nov 2;1(4):e91. doi: 10.4081/cp.2011.e91. eCollection 2011 Sep 28.
Previous studies in USA and Canada have found that physicians and physicians in training have a limited understanding of medical care costs. In this study, we set out to survey all grades of doctors in the surgical department, emergency department, and anaesthetic department in a university-affiliated, Irish teaching hospital. Open-ended questionnaires on cost of 25 routinely used items in the hospital were sent to each department. The aims of the study were to assess the present knowledge of cost among the various grades of doctors, and to evaluate the level of professional experience on cost awareness and their confidence in their estimates. We had an overall response rate of 56.8% with 68.5% of doctors admitted to have estimated more than 90% of their responses. Ninety three percent of doctors have no confidence in their estimates on cost of listed items. We found that the lack of cost awareness was universal among doctors of all grades (P = 0.236). The doctors in our study population showed a high level of inaccuracy on their estimates of cost of routinely used items with 84% of the items overestimated. Our results were discouraging and demonstrated that considerable educational activity will be necessary if doctors are to be more cost effective in meeting the national health care budget.
美国和加拿大此前的研究发现,执业医生和实习医生对医疗成本的了解有限。在本研究中,我们着手对一家爱尔兰大学附属医院的外科、急诊科和麻醉科的各级医生进行调查。向每个科室发放了关于医院25种常用物品成本的开放式问卷。该研究的目的是评估各级医生目前对成本的了解情况,并评估专业经验水平对成本意识的影响以及他们对自己估计的信心。我们的总体回复率为56.8%,68.5%的医生承认他们估计的回复率超过了90%。93%的医生对他们列出的物品成本估计没有信心。我们发现,各级医生普遍缺乏成本意识(P = 0.236)。我们研究人群中的医生对常用物品成本的估计存在高度不准确,84%的物品被高估。我们的结果令人沮丧,表明如果医生要在满足国家医疗保健预算方面更具成本效益,就需要开展大量的教育活动。