Roberts M, Lamont E
Division of Nursing & Counselling, University of Abertay, Dundee, UK.
J Psychiatr Ment Health Nurs. 2014 Dec;21(10):873-8. doi: 10.1111/jpm.12155. Epub 2014 May 4.
The phenomenon of suicide is one of the primary concerns for mental health professions. The health-care literature is dominated by discussions that focus variously on local and national suicide prevention policies, on the assessment of those individuals judged to be at risk of committing suicide as well as the appropriateness and efficacy of interventions for those who express suicidal ideation and display suicidal behaviours. What appear less frequently in the literature, however, are critical analyses of the concept of suicide and, in particular, critical reflections on the manner in which the concept of suicide has been, and continues to be, understood or 'framed'. In an attempt to respond to this apparent omission, this paper will suggest that the work of Albert Camus, and his philosophical work The Myth of Sisyphus in particular, can be understood as providing a significant reconceptualization and reframing of suicide. In doing so, it will be suggested that Camus's work not only challenges how the concept of suicide has traditionally been situated within the context of mental illness, but can also be understood as challenging the efficacy of the interventions that have been associated with an understanding of suicide within that context.
自杀现象是心理健康专业人士主要关注的问题之一。医疗保健文献中充斥着各种讨论,这些讨论分别聚焦于地方和国家的自杀预防政策、对那些被判定有自杀风险的个体的评估,以及对那些表达自杀意念和表现出自杀行为的人所采取干预措施的适当性和有效性。然而,文献中较少出现的是对自杀概念的批判性分析,尤其是对自杀概念一直以来以及持续被理解或 “构建” 方式的批判性反思。为了回应这一明显的疏漏,本文将提出,阿尔贝·加缪的作品,尤其是他的哲学著作《西西弗神话》,可以被理解为对自杀进行了重大的重新概念化和重新构建。这样做的同时,本文将表明,加缪的作品不仅挑战了自杀概念传统上在精神疾病背景下的定位方式,还可以被理解为挑战了在该背景下与对自杀的理解相关的干预措施的有效性。