O'Brien Kelly K, Solomon Patricia, Trentham Barry, MacLachlan Duncan, MacDermid Joy, Tynan Anne-Marie, Baxter Larry, Casey Alan, Chegwidden William, Robinson Greg, Tran Todd, Wu Janet, Zack Elisse
Department of Physical Therapy, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada School of Rehabilitation Science, McMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada Canadian Working Group on HIV and Rehabilitation, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
School of Rehabilitation Science, McMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada.
BMJ Open. 2014 May 14;4(5):e004692. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2013-004692.
Our aim was to develop evidence-informed recommendations for rehabilitation with older adults living with HIV.
We conducted a knowledge synthesis, combining research evidence specific to HIV, rehabilitation and ageing, with evidence on rehabilitation interventions for common comorbidities experienced by older adults with HIV.
We included highly relevant HIV-specific research addressing rehabilitation and ageing (stream A) and high-quality evidence on the effectiveness of rehabilitation interventions for common comorbidities experienced by older adults ageing with HIV (stream B). We extracted and synthesised relevant data from the evidence to draft evidence-informed recommendations for rehabilitation. Draft recommendations were refined based on people living with HIV (PLHIV) and clinician experience, values and preferences, reviewed by an interprofessional team for Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development, and Evaluation (GRADE) (quality) rating and revision and then circulated to PLHIV and clinicians for external endorsement and final refinement. We then devised overarching recommendations to broadly guide rehabilitation with older adults living with HIV.
This synthesis yielded 8 overarching and 52 specific recommendations. Thirty-six specific recommendations were derived from 108 moderate-level or high-level research articles (meta-analyses and systematic reviews) that described the effectiveness of rehabilitation interventions for comorbidities that may be experienced by older adults with HIV. Recommendations addressed rehabilitation interventions across eight health conditions: bone and joint disorders, cancer, stroke, cardiovascular disease, mental health challenges, cognitive impairments, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and diabetes. Sixteen specific recommendations were derived from 42 research articles specific to rehabilitation with older adults with HIV. The quality of evidence from which these recommendations were derived was either low or very low, consisting primarily of narrative reviews or descriptive studies with small sample sizes. Recommendations addressed approaches to rehabilitation assessment and interventions, and contextual factors to consider for rehabilitation with older adults living with HIV.
These evidence-informed recommendations provide a guide for rehabilitation with older adults living with HIV.
我们的目标是为感染艾滋病毒的老年人制定基于证据的康复建议。
我们进行了一项知识综合研究,将艾滋病毒、康复和老龄化方面的特定研究证据与艾滋病毒感染老年人常见合并症的康复干预证据相结合。
我们纳入了与康复和老龄化相关的高度相关的艾滋病毒特定研究(A组)以及关于艾滋病毒感染老年人常见合并症康复干预效果的高质量证据(B组)。我们从证据中提取并综合相关数据,以起草基于证据的康复建议。根据艾滋病毒感染者(PLHIV)和临床医生的经验、价值观和偏好对建议草案进行完善,由一个跨专业团队进行审查,以进行推荐评估、制定和评价分级(GRADE)(质量)评级和修订,然后分发给艾滋病毒感染者和临床医生进行外部认可和最终完善。然后,我们制定了总体建议,以广泛指导艾滋病毒感染老年人的康复。
该综合研究产生了8项总体建议和52项具体建议。36项具体建议来自108篇中级或高级研究文章(荟萃分析和系统评价),这些文章描述了康复干预对艾滋病毒感染老年人可能出现的合并症的有效性。建议涉及八种健康状况的康复干预:骨骼和关节疾病、癌症、中风、心血管疾病、心理健康挑战、认知障碍、慢性阻塞性肺疾病和糖尿病。16项具体建议来自42篇关于艾滋病毒感染老年人康复的特定研究文章。这些建议所依据的证据质量低或非常低,主要包括叙述性综述或小样本描述性研究。建议涉及康复评估和干预方法,以及艾滋病毒感染老年人康复时应考虑的背景因素。
这些基于证据的建议为艾滋病毒感染老年人的康复提供了指导。