Shahly Victoria, Kessler Ronald C, Duncan Ian
1 Department of Health Care Policy, Harvard Medical School , Boston, Massachusetts.
Popul Health Manag. 2014 Oct;17(5):306-15. doi: 10.1089/pop.2013.0095. Epub 2014 May 16.
Despite levels of health spending that are higher per capita and as share of gross domestic product than any country worldwide, the US health care system is fragmented, technology and administration heavy, and primary care deficient. Studies of regional variations in US health care show similar "disconnects" between higher spending and better health outcomes. Faced with rising health benefit costs and suboptimal workforce health amid economic downturn, concerned US employers have implemented innovative payment and health care delivery strategies such as consumer-driven health plans and targeted prevention programs. The former may impose undue cost shifting, prohibitive out-of-pocket expenses, and health literacy challenges, while the latter have shown inconsistent near-term economic returns and long-term clinical efficacy. Employers have begun exploring more comprehensive health delivery platforms such as integrated worksite primary care clinics that have potential to cost-effectively address several pressing problems with current US health care: the growing primary care physician shortage, poor access to routine care, lack of coordinated and patient-centered treatment models, low rates of childhood immunizations, and "quality-blind" fee-for-service payment mechanisms. Such on-site medical clinics exploit one of the rare comparative strengths of the US health care system-its plentiful supply of highly skilled registered nurses-to offer workers and their dependents convenient, high-quality, affordable care. A relatively recent health care paradigm, worksite clinics must yet develop consistent reporting strategies and credible demonstration of outcomes. This review explores available evidence regarding worksite primary care clinics, including current rationale, historical trends, prevalence and projected growth, expected health and financial benefits, challenges, and future research directions.
尽管美国人均医疗支出及其占国内生产总值的比例高于世界上任何国家,但美国医疗体系却分散、技术和管理负担重且初级保健不足。对美国医疗区域差异的研究表明,在较高支出与更好健康结果之间存在类似的“脱节”现象。面对经济衰退期间不断上升的医保成本和欠佳的劳动力健康状况,忧心忡忡的美国雇主实施了创新的支付方式和医疗服务提供策略,如消费者驱动型医保计划和针对性预防项目。前者可能会导致不当的成本转嫁、过高的自付费用以及健康素养方面的挑战,而后者的近期经济回报和长期临床疗效并不稳定。雇主们已开始探索更全面的医疗服务平台,如综合工作场所初级保健诊所,这类诊所有可能以成本效益高的方式解决当前美国医疗体系的几个紧迫问题:初级保健医生日益短缺、常规医疗服务获取困难、缺乏协调且以患者为中心的治疗模式、儿童免疫接种率低以及“质量盲目”的按服务收费支付机制。此类现场医疗诊所利用了美国医疗体系中一项罕见的相对优势——大量高技能注册护士的充足供应——为员工及其家属提供方便、高质量且负担得起的医疗服务。作为一种相对较新的医疗模式,工作场所诊所仍需制定一致的报告策略并切实证明其成效。本综述探讨了有关工作场所初级保健诊所的现有证据,包括当前的理论依据、历史趋势、患病率及预计增长情况、预期的健康和经济效益、挑战以及未来的研究方向。