Melo Juliana, Kaneshiro Bliss, Kellett Lisa, Hiraoka Mark
Department Of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Denver School of Medicine, University of Colorado, Denver CO (JM).
Hawaii J Med Public Health. 2014 May;73(5):144-7.
Clinical training in most medical schools consists of separate rotations, based out of tertiary-care facilities, across the core medical disciplines. In addition to a traditional clinical curriculum, the University of Hawai'i offers a longitudinal clinical curriculum as an option to medical students. The longitudinal curriculum provides students with an innovative, alternative educational track to achieve their educational goals in clinical medicine. The objective of this study was to describe the obstetrics and gynecology procedural experiences of third-year medical students who participated in a longitudinal curriculum versus a traditional block clerkship. The number of procedures reported by third-year medical students who participated in a non-traditional, longitudinal clerkship was compared with the number of procedures reported by students who participated in the traditional block third-year curriculum between July 2007 and June 2009. National Board of Medical Examiners (NBME) subject scores, clerkship grade and chosen residency specialty were also compared. The mean number of pelvic exams (longitudinally-trained 36 [SD 33] versus block-trained 8 [SD 6], [t=4.3, P<.01]) and pap smears (longitudinally-trained 28 [SD 26] versus block-trained 7 [SD 3] [t=4.4, P<.01]) was significantly higher for longitudinally-trained students compared to block-trained students. No significant differences in overall clerkship grades or NBME shelf scores emerged.
大多数医学院校的临床培训是在三级医疗设施基础上,针对核心医学学科进行单独轮转。除了传统的临床课程外,夏威夷大学还为医学生提供了一种纵向临床课程作为选择。纵向课程为学生提供了一条创新的、替代性的教育途径,以实现他们在临床医学方面的教育目标。本研究的目的是描述参与纵向课程的三年级医学生与参与传统集中实习的三年级医学生在妇产科手术方面的经历。比较了2007年7月至2009年6月期间参与非传统纵向实习的三年级医学生报告的手术数量与参与传统三年级集中课程的学生报告的手术数量。还比较了美国国家医学考试委员会(NBME)学科成绩、实习成绩和所选的住院医师专业。纵向培训的学生进行盆腔检查的平均次数(纵向培训36次[标准差33],集中培训8次[标准差6],[t = 4.3,P <.01])和巴氏涂片检查的平均次数(纵向培训28次[标准差26],集中培训7次[标准差3],[t = 4.4,P <.01])显著高于集中培训的学生。在总体实习成绩或NBME结业考试成绩方面没有出现显著差异。