Salloum Naji C, McCarthy Michael J, Leckband Susan G, Kelsoe John R
Department of Psychiatry (0603), University of California San Diego, La Jolla, CA 92093, USA.
BMC Med. 2014 May 30;12:90. doi: 10.1186/1741-7015-12-90.
Bipolar disorder (BD) is a psychiatric illness defined by pathological alterations between the mood states of mania and depression, causing disability, imposing healthcare costs and elevating the risk of suicide. Although effective treatments for BD exist, variability in outcomes leads to a large number of treatment failures, typically followed by a trial and error process of medication switches that can take years. Pharmacogenetic testing (PGT), by tailoring drug choice to an individual, may personalize and expedite treatment so as to identify more rapidly medications well suited to individual BD patients.
A number of associations have been made in BD between medication response phenotypes and specific genetic markers. However, to date clinical adoption of PGT has been limited, often citing questions that must be answered before it can be widely utilized. These include: What are the requirements of supporting evidence? How large is a clinically relevant effect? What degree of specificity and sensitivity are required? Does a given marker influence decision making and have clinical utility? In many cases, the answers to these questions remain unknown, and ultimately, the question of whether PGT is valid and useful must be determined empirically. Towards this aim, we have reviewed the literature and selected drug-genotype associations with the strongest evidence for utility in BD.
Based upon these findings, we propose a preliminary panel for use in PGT, and a method by which the results of a PGT panel can be integrated for clinical interpretation. Finally, we argue that based on the sufficiency of accumulated evidence, PGT implementation studies are now warranted. We propose and discuss the design for a randomized clinical trial to test the use of PGT in the treatment of BD.
双相情感障碍(BD)是一种精神疾病,其特征为躁狂和抑郁情绪状态之间的病理性改变,会导致残疾、产生医疗费用并增加自杀风险。尽管存在有效的BD治疗方法,但治疗结果的变异性导致大量治疗失败,通常随后会经历数年的药物转换试错过程。药物遗传学检测(PGT)通过根据个体情况选择药物,可实现治疗的个性化并加快治疗进程,从而更快地为BD患者确定更适合的药物。
在BD中,药物反应表型与特定基因标记之间已建立了多种关联。然而,迄今为止,PGT在临床中的应用有限,人们常常提出在其能够广泛应用之前必须回答的问题。这些问题包括:支持证据的要求是什么?临床相关效应有多大?需要何种程度的特异性和敏感性?特定标记是否会影响决策并具有临床实用性?在许多情况下,这些问题的答案仍然未知,最终,PGT是否有效和有用的问题必须通过实证来确定。为了实现这一目标,我们回顾了文献并选择了在BD中具有最强实用证据的药物-基因型关联。
基于这些发现,我们提出了一个用于PGT的初步检测组,以及一种整合PGT检测组结果以进行临床解读的方法。最后,我们认为基于积累证据的充分性,现在有必要开展PGT实施研究。我们提出并讨论了一项随机临床试验的设计,以测试PGT在BD治疗中的应用。