Ouaïssi Mehdi, Turrini Olivier, Hubert Catherine, Louis Guillaume, Gigot Jean-François, Mabrut Jean-Yves
Department of Digestive Surgery, Timone Hospital, Marseille, France.
J Hepatobiliary Pancreat Sci. 2014 Sep;21(9):623-38. doi: 10.1002/jhbp.122. Epub 2014 May 30.
This literature review aimed to critically analyze oncological results of vascular resection during pancreatectomy for adenocarcinoma in the light of the concept evolution of locally advanced tumors and microscopic complete resection. The literature search was conducted in PubMed and Medline for the period June 1994 to December 2012, retaining English as the language of publication. The review of 12 publications indicated that mortality and morbidity rates were not significantly different for pancreatectomy with or without venous resection (VR). Six comparative studies showed worse long-term survival in the VR group, though one meta-analysis, albeit with a significant population heterogeneity, demonstrated that the overall survival between VR and the control group was similar (12% vs. 17%). The compilation of 13 comparative studies showed a significantly lower rate of complete microscopic resection in the VR patient group compared to controls (63% vs. 77%; P = 0.001). Concerning pancreatectomy combined to arterial resection, the literature review indicated a significantly greater mortality and morbidity rate and a lower survival rate compared to pancreatic resection alone. Conflicting results concerning the long-term outcome of VR was due to the heterogeneity of the patient population. Since the only chance to cure patients of pancreatic adenocarcinoma is to obtain free resection margins, VR is a valid therapeutic option. But combined arterial resection to pancreatic resection does not appear to be recommended.
本综述旨在根据局部晚期肿瘤概念的演变和显微镜下完整切除的情况,批判性地分析胰腺癌胰十二指肠切除术中血管切除的肿瘤学结果。在1994年6月至2012年12月期间,通过PubMed和Medline进行文献检索,仅保留英文发表的文献。对12篇出版物的综述表明,有或无静脉切除(VR)的胰十二指肠切除术的死亡率和发病率无显著差异。六项比较研究显示VR组的长期生存率较差,尽管一项荟萃分析(尽管存在显著的人群异质性)表明VR组与对照组的总生存率相似(12%对17%)。13项比较研究的汇总显示,VR患者组的显微镜下完整切除率明显低于对照组(63%对77%;P = 0.001)。关于联合动脉切除的胰十二指肠切除术,文献综述表明,与单纯胰腺切除术相比,其死亡率和发病率显著更高,生存率更低。VR长期结果的矛盾结果归因于患者人群的异质性。由于治愈胰腺癌患者的唯一机会是获得切缘阴性,VR是一种有效的治疗选择。但不建议联合动脉切除与胰腺切除术。