Weber Buchholz Susan, Wilbur JoEllen, Halloway Shannon, McDevitt Judith H, Schoeny Michael E
Annu Rev Nurs Res. 2013;31:71-142. doi: 10.1891/0739-6686.31.71.
Engaging in regular physical activity is a key component for maintaining a healthy weight and preventing overweight and obesity. Obesity continues to be a concern globally, especially for women, and women are less physically active than men. This systematic review examined current research on physical activity interventions designed for healthy community dwelling women and assessed the effects of those interventions on physical activity and body composition. Three author-developed data collection tools were used to extract and examine study variables. For studies with suitable data, effect sizes were obtained. The initial search identified 1,406 titles published between 2000 and 2012, of which 40 randomized clinical trials met inclusion criteria. Of these 40 studies, 16 had a physical activity intervention that did not have a diet component and 24 had a physical activity intervention along with a diet component. The overall weighted mean effect was d = .21, 95% CI [0.06, 0.36] for physical activity outcomes (n = 18 studies) and d = -.16, 95% CI [-0.22, -0.09] for body composition outcomes (n = 24 studies). Both physical activity interventions without and with a diet component were effective in promoting physical activity and improving body composition. Physical activity interventions without a diet component were more effective than physical activity interventions with a diet component at promoting physical activity. The most effective interventions need to be adapted for dissemination into practice.
进行规律的体育活动是维持健康体重、预防超重和肥胖的关键因素。肥胖仍是全球关注的问题,尤其是对女性而言,而且女性的体育活动比男性少。本系统评价考察了针对居住在社区的健康女性设计的体育活动干预措施的现有研究,并评估了这些干预措施对体育活动和身体成分的影响。使用了三种作者开发的数据收集工具来提取和检验研究变量。对于有合适数据的研究,计算效应量。初步检索确定了2000年至2012年发表的1406篇文献标题,其中40项随机临床试验符合纳入标准。在这40项研究中,16项进行了无饮食成分的体育活动干预,24项进行了有饮食成分的体育活动干预。体育活动结果(n = 18项研究)的总体加权平均效应为d = 0.21,95%CI [0.06, 0.36];身体成分结果(n = 24项研究)的总体加权平均效应为d = -0.16,95%CI [-0.22, -0.09]。无饮食成分和有饮食成分的体育活动干预在促进体育活动和改善身体成分方面均有效。在促进体育活动方面,无饮食成分的体育活动干预比有饮食成分的体育活动干预更有效。最有效的干预措施需要进行调整以便推广应用于实践。