Chamberlin C J, Magill R A
Department of Kinesiology, University of Northern Colorado, Greeley 80639.
Res Q Exerc Sport. 1989 Sep;60(3):256-67. doi: 10.1080/02701367.1989.10607449.
Research investigating the preparation and control of rapid, multisegmented responses typically has assumed complete programming of the response occurring prior to movement initiation and has made use of a simple reaction time (RT) paradigm. A notable exception is Rosenbaum's work which proposed the Hierarchical Editor (HED) model that is specifically directed toward the control of movements in the choice environment. The purposes of this study were to investigate the assumption of complete programming prior to movement initiation and to compare predictions of the HED model with other programming models. Three experiments are reported in which subjects were required to tap either one, two, or three plates as rapidly as possible in either a simple or choice RT situation. The results were very consistent in these experiments even with several modifications in apparatus and methodology. Of particular interest were effects of movement complexity on RT and movement time (MT) for the first and second segments of the movement (M1 and M2). Choice RT (CRT) results consistently showed no increases in RT as the number of movement segments increased but showed significant increases in M1. For simple RT situations, however, there were small but consistent increases in RT as well as increases in M1 with increases in the number of movement parts. For both CRT and SRT results, small but nonsignificant increases were noted for M2. These results provide evidence for incomplete programming prior to response initiation. Although the SRT data can be accommodated by Henry's theory, the HED model appears to offer the best overall fit for the results.
研究快速多段反应的准备和控制通常假定反应在运动开始前已完全编程,并采用了简单反应时(RT)范式。一个显著的例外是罗森鲍姆的研究,他提出了层次编辑器(HED)模型,该模型专门针对选择环境中的运动控制。本研究的目的是调查运动开始前完全编程的假设,并将HED模型的预测与其他编程模型进行比较。报告了三个实验,要求受试者在简单或选择反应时情境中尽可能快地敲击一、二或三个盘子。即使在仪器和方法上有一些修改,这些实验的结果也非常一致。特别令人感兴趣的是运动复杂性对运动的第一段和第二段(M1和M2)的反应时和运动时间(MT)的影响。选择反应时(CRT)结果始终表明,随着运动段数的增加,反应时没有增加,但M1有显著增加。然而,对于简单反应时情境,随着运动部件数量的增加,反应时有小但一致的增加,M1也增加。对于CRT和SRT结果,M2都有小但不显著的增加。这些结果为反应开始前编程不完全提供了证据。虽然SRT数据可以用亨利的理论来解释,但HED模型似乎最能整体拟合这些结果。