Chamberlin Steven R, Oberg Erica, Hanes Douglas A, Calabrese Carlo
National College of Naturopathic Medicine, Portland, OR, USA.
Pacific Pearl La Jolla, La Jolla, CA, USA.
Integr Med Insights. 2014 May 19;9:7-15. doi: 10.4137/IMI.S14124. eCollection 2014.
This study collected patient visit data to explore similarities and differences between conventional and naturopathic primary care (PC). Administrative data from practice management software systems from the main teaching clinics of four of the eight accredited North American naturopathic academic institutions were abstracted into an integrated database containing five years (2006-2010) of visit, patient, laboratory, and prescribing data. Descriptive analyses of healthcare services were compared to the National Ambulatory Medical Care Survey (NAMCS). Over the five-year period, 300,483 patient visits to naturopathic doctors occurred at clinics, excluding visits at clinics operated by the schools in community settings. Patients were 69% female; mean age was 39 (SE 0.09). Older adults (>65) comprised 9% of the population and children (<16) comprised 8%. Comparing academic naturopathic clinics to national conventional PC (NAMCS), we found more patients paid out of pocket at naturopathic clinics (50 vs. 4%) and naturopathic clinics more frequently offered discounted care (26 vs. 0.3%). There was a 44% overlap in the most frequent 25 diagnoses for PC at conventional community clinics. Overall, these data suggest substantial similarities in care offered by academic naturopathic clinics, at which most Naturopathic Doctor (ND) students are trained, and by conventional PC practices.
本研究收集了患者就诊数据,以探讨传统初级保健(PC)与自然疗法初级保健之间的异同。从北美八所获得认证的自然疗法学术机构中的四所主要教学诊所的实践管理软件系统中提取行政数据,纳入一个综合数据库,该数据库包含五年(2006 - 2010年)的就诊、患者、实验室和处方数据。将医疗服务的描述性分析结果与国家门诊医疗调查(NAMCS)进行比较。在这五年期间,在诊所发生了300,483次患者就诊于自然疗法医生的情况,不包括学校在社区环境中运营的诊所的就诊。患者中69%为女性;平均年龄为39岁(标准误0.09)。老年人(>65岁)占人口的9%,儿童(<16岁)占8%。将学术性自然疗法诊所与全国传统初级保健(NAMCS)进行比较,我们发现自然疗法诊所自费支付的患者更多(50%对4%),且自然疗法诊所更频繁地提供折扣护理(26%对0.3%)。在传统社区诊所中,初级保健最常见的25种诊断中有44%重叠。总体而言,这些数据表明,在大多数自然疗法医生(ND)学生接受培训的学术性自然疗法诊所提供的护理与传统初级保健实践提供的护理有很大相似之处。