McPoil Thomas G, Cornwall Mark W, Taylor Olivia, Pomeroy Mary, Mufti Judy, Kuhlman Holly, Ehlers Derrik, Carrell Drew
J Am Podiatr Med Assoc. 2014 May;104(3):247-52. doi: 10.7547/0003-0538-104.3.247.
Several studies have reported the necessity of using a standardized foot placement to improve reliability when performing standing foot posture measurements. The intent of this study was to determine whether individuals can reliably place their feet in the same standing position after marching in place or whether the standing position must be determined by a rater observing the angle and base of gait during walking to ensure the consistency of foot placement.
Twenty individuals (12 women and 8 men; mean age, 24.8 years) consented to participate. All of the participants were asked to march in place for 10 sec and then to stop in their preferred angle and base foot placement. Participants then walked over an 8-m walkway so that one of two raters could observe the participant's angle and base while walking. An angle and base of gait tracing was then made for each participant's foot placement.
The two raters and all of the participants demonstrated high levels of reliability for foot placement between the two sessions. The results indicate that asking the participant to march in place provides a more consistent angle and base foot placement between two sessions compared with having a rater determine the angle and base of gait foot placement after observing the participant while walking.
Based on these findings, we recommend using marching in place to position a patient in his or her angle and base foot placement when the measurement or visual assessment of foot posture must be performed for more than one clinical visit.
多项研究报告称,在进行站立足部姿势测量时,使用标准化的足部位置摆放以提高可靠性很有必要。本研究的目的是确定个体在原地踏步后是否能够可靠地将双脚放置在相同的站立位置,或者站立位置是否必须由评估者在步行过程中观察步态角度和步幅来确定,以确保足部位置摆放的一致性。
20名个体(12名女性和8名男性;平均年龄24.8岁)同意参与。所有参与者被要求原地踏步10秒,然后以他们偏好的角度和双脚位置摆放停下。参与者随后走过一条8米长的通道,以便两名评估者中的一名能够在步行过程中观察参与者的角度和步幅。然后针对每位参与者的足部位置摆放绘制步态角度和步幅图。
两名评估者以及所有参与者在两次测试之间的足部位置摆放显示出高度的可靠性。结果表明,与让评估者在观察参与者行走后确定步态足部位置的角度和步幅相比,要求参与者原地踏步在两次测试之间能提供更一致的角度和双脚位置摆放。
基于这些发现,我们建议当必须针对不止一次临床就诊进行足部姿势的测量或视觉评估时,使用原地踏步来确定患者的角度和双脚位置摆放。