Hunt Charlotte M, Widener Gail, Allen Diane D
C.M. Hunt, BS, Graduate Program in Physical Therapy, University of California San Francisco/San Francisco State University, 1600 Holloway Ave, HSS 112, San Francisco, CA 94132 (USA).
G. Widener, PT, PhD, Doctor of Physical Therapy Program, Samuel Merritt University, Oakland, California.
Phys Ther. 2014 Oct;94(10):1489-98. doi: 10.2522/ptj.20130288. Epub 2014 Jun 5.
People with multiple sclerosis (MS) have diminished postural control, and center of pressure (COP) displacement varies more in this population than in healthy controls. Balance-based torso-weighting (BBTW) can improve clinical balance and mobility in people with MS, and exploration using both linear and nonlinear measures of COP may help determine whether BBTW optimizes movement variability.
The aim of this study was to investigate the effects of BBTW on people with MS and healthy controls during quiet standing.
This was a quasi-experimental study comparing COP variability between groups, between eye closure conditions, and between weighting conditions in the anterior-posterior and medial-lateral directions.
Twenty participants with MS and 18 healthy controls stood on a forceplate in 4 conditions: eyes open and closed and with and without BBTW. Linear measures of COP displacement included range and root mean square (RMS). Nonlinear measures included approximate entropy (ApEn) and Lyapunov exponent (LyE). Three-way repeated-measures analyses of variance compared measures across groups and conditions. The association between weighting response and baseline nonlinear variables was examined. When significant associations were found, MS subgroups were created and compared.
The MS and control groups had significantly different range, RMS, and ApEn values. The eyes-open and eyes-closed conditions had significantly different range and RMS values. Change with weighting correlated with LyE (r=-.70) and ApEn (r=-.59). Two MS subgroups, with low and high baseline LyE values, responded to BBTW in opposite directions, with a significant main effect for weighting condition for the LyE variable in the medial-lateral direction.
The small samples and no identification of impairments related to LyE at baseline were limitations of the study.
The LyE may help differentiate subgroups who respond differently to BBTW. In both subgroups, LyE values moved toward the average of healthy controls, suggesting that BBTW may help optimize movement variability in people with MS.
多发性硬化症(MS)患者的姿势控制能力下降,与健康对照者相比,该人群的压力中心(COP)位移变化更大。基于平衡的躯干加权(BBTW)可改善MS患者的临床平衡和活动能力,使用COP的线性和非线性测量方法进行探索可能有助于确定BBTW是否能优化运动变异性。
本研究旨在调查BBTW对MS患者和健康对照者安静站立时的影响。
这是一项准实验研究,比较了两组之间、闭眼条件之间以及前后和内外方向加权条件下的COP变异性。
20名MS患者和18名健康对照者在4种条件下站在测力板上:睁眼和闭眼,以及有和没有BBTW。COP位移的线性测量包括范围和均方根(RMS)。非线性测量包括近似熵(ApEn)和李雅普诺夫指数(LyE)。采用三因素重复测量方差分析比较不同组和条件下的测量值。研究了加权反应与基线非线性变量之间的关联。当发现显著关联时,创建并比较MS亚组。
MS组和对照组的范围、RMS和ApEn值有显著差异。睁眼和闭眼条件下的范围和RMS值有显著差异。加权变化与LyE(r = -0.70)和ApEn(r = -0.59)相关。两个MS亚组,基线LyE值低和高,对BBTW的反应方向相反,在内外侧方向上,LyE变量的加权条件有显著的主效应。
样本量小以及基线时未识别与LyE相关的损伤是本研究的局限性。
LyE可能有助于区分对BBTW反应不同的亚组。在两个亚组中,LyE值均朝着健康对照者的平均值移动,这表明BBTW可能有助于优化MS患者的运动变异性。