Hirnstein Marco, Coloma Andrews Lisa, Hausmann Markus
Department of Biological and Medical Psychology, University of Bergen, Jonas Lies vei 91, 5009, Bergen, Norway,
Arch Sex Behav. 2014 Nov;43(8):1663-73. doi: 10.1007/s10508-014-0311-5. Epub 2014 Jun 13.
Sex differences in specific cognitive abilities are well documented, but the biological, psychological, and sociocultural interactions that may underlie these differences are largely unknown. We examined within a biopsychosocial approach how gender stereotypes affect cognitive sex differences when adult participants were tested in mixed- or same-sex groups. A total of 136 participants (70 women) were allocated to either mixed- or same-sex groups and completed a battery of sex-sensitive cognitive tests (i.e., mental rotation, verbal fluency, perceptual speed) after gender stereotypes or gender-neutral stereotypes (control) were activated. To study the potential role of testosterone as a mediator for group sex composition and stereotype boost/threat effects, saliva samples were taken before the stereotype manipulation and after cognitive testing. The results showed the typical male and female advantages in mental rotation and verbal fluency, respectively. In general, men and women who were tested in mixed-sex groups and whose gender stereotypes had not been activated performed best. Moreover, a stereotype threat effect emerged in verbal fluency with reduced performance in gender stereotyped men but not women. Testosterone levels did not mediate the effects of group sex composition and stereotype threat nor did we find any relationship between testosterone and cognitive performance in men and women. Taken together, the findings suggest that an interaction of gender stereotyping and group sex composition affects the performance of men and women in sex-sensitive cognitive tasks. Mixed-sex settings can, in fact, increase cognitive performance as long as gender-stereotyping is prevented.
特定认知能力方面的性别差异已有充分记录,但这些差异背后可能存在的生物学、心理学和社会文化相互作用在很大程度上尚不清楚。我们采用生物心理社会方法,研究了在成年参与者以混合性别或同性别群体接受测试时,性别刻板印象如何影响认知性别差异。总共136名参与者(70名女性)被分配到混合性别或同性别群体中,并在激活性别刻板印象或中性刻板印象(对照组)后,完成了一系列对性别敏感的认知测试(即心理旋转、言语流畅性、知觉速度)。为了研究睾酮作为群体性别构成与刻板印象提升/威胁效应中介的潜在作用,在刻板印象操纵前和认知测试后采集了唾液样本。结果分别显示了男性在心理旋转方面以及女性在言语流畅性方面的典型优势。总体而言,在混合性别群体中接受测试且其性别刻板印象未被激活的男性和女性表现最佳。此外,在言语流畅性方面出现了刻板印象威胁效应,性别刻板印象中的男性表现下降,而女性没有。睾酮水平并未介导群体性别构成和刻板印象威胁的影响,我们也未发现睾酮与男性和女性认知表现之间存在任何关系。综上所述,研究结果表明,性别刻板印象与群体性别构成的相互作用会影响男性和女性在对性别敏感的认知任务中的表现。事实上,只要防止性别刻板印象,混合性别环境就能提高认知表现。