Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, University of Catania, 95125 Catania, Italy.
Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Box 352700, University of Washington Seattle, WA 98195-2700, United States.
Water Res. 2014 Oct 1;62:117-26. doi: 10.1016/j.watres.2014.05.024. Epub 2014 Jun 2.
This study investigated effects of pH, bromide and natural organic matter (NOM) level on yields and speciation of trihalomethanes (THMs) and haloacetic acids (HAAs) in chlorinated water. Experimental data were obtained using two water sources, one with a medium (DOC = 1.4 mg/L and SUVA = 2.60 L mg(-1) m(-1)) and the other with higher (DOC = 7.7 mg/L and SUVA = 4.26 L mg(-1) m(-1)) organic carbon level. The experiments employed the simulated distribution system (SDS) procedure at varying bromide concentrations and pH values of 7.0, 8.5 and 10. The speciation of THMs and dihalogenated HAAs (DHAAs) was interpreted based on the modelling of mixed halogenation yields via dimensionless ratios of bromination/chlorination reaction rates at each halogen incorporation node. The approach allowed precise modelling of the speciation of THMs and DHAAs at all examined pHs. In the case of DHAA, the dimensionless ratios of the bromination/chlorination reaction rates were not consistently affected by pH variations. For THMs, increase of pH caused the values of the dimensionless bromination/chlorination reaction rates to decrease in the case of halogenation of the initial reaction sites indicating a decreasing preference toward bromination at this reaction node. A similar trend was observed for the reactivity of dichlorinated reaction intermediate denoted as SCl2 whose formation precedes the release of CHCl3 and CHBrCl2. A similar but less consistent trend was observed for intermediate SBrCl whose halogenation yields both CHBrCl2 and CHBr2Cl. An opposite trend of increasing preference towards bromination at higher pHs was observed monobrominated intermediate SBr and in some extent dibrominated intermediate SBr2. These results help develop detailed DBP speciation models which needed to better understand the generation and potential health effects of THMs and HAAs at varying operating conditions and ultimately to adopt measure to minimize their levels in drinking water systems.
本研究考察了 pH 值、溴化物和天然有机物(NOM)水平对氯化水中三卤甲烷(THMs)和卤乙酸(HAAs)生成和形态的影响。实验数据来自两种水源,一种水的有机碳含量中等(DOC=1.4mg/L,SUVA=2.60Lmg(-1)m(-1)),另一种水的有机碳含量较高(DOC=7.7mg/L,SUVA=4.26Lmg(-1)m(-1))。实验采用模拟分配系统(SDS)程序,在不同溴化物浓度和 pH 值(7.0、8.5 和 10.0)下进行。通过每个卤素结合节点处溴化/氯化反应速率的无量纲比来解释 THMs 和二卤代 HAAs(DHAAs)的形态。该方法允许在所有考察的 pH 值下精确模拟 THMs 和 DHAAs 的形态。对于 DHAA,溴化/氯化反应速率的无量纲比不受 pH 变化的影响。对于 THMs,pH 值的升高导致初始反应位点卤化时溴化/氯化反应速率的无量纲值降低,表明在该反应节点上溴化的偏好降低。对于二氯代反应中间体 SCl2 的反应性也观察到了类似的趋势,其形成先于 CHCl3 和 CHBrCl2 的释放。对于 SBrCl 中间体的形成也观察到了类似但不太一致的趋势,其卤化产物既包括 CHBrCl2 也包括 CHBr2Cl。在较高 pH 值下观察到 SBr 单溴化中间体和在一定程度上 SBr2 二溴化中间体对溴化的偏好增加,这是一个相反的趋势。这些结果有助于开发详细的 DBP 形态模型,以更好地理解在不同运行条件下 THMs 和 HAAs 的生成及其潜在健康影响,并最终采取措施将其在饮用水系统中的水平降至最低。