Cayce Rachael, Bergstresser Paul, Hesterman Kathleen, Condie Daniel
J Grad Med Educ. 2014 Jun;6(2):296-300. doi: 10.4300/JGME-D-13-00272.1.
Physicians in specialties other than dermatology care for the majority of patients with skin diseases, yet most physicians receive little training in dermatology.
The primary objective of this study was to determine whether there would be a sizable (20%) improvement in posttraining scores for internal medicine residents after completing 1 of 3 assigned curricula. A secondary objective was to determine whether there were significant differences in improvement among the 3 resident cohorts after completing their curriculum. Finally, we explored the residents' change in perceived clinical knowledge postcurriculum.
Thirty-six postgraduate year 2 internal medicine residents were randomized to complete 1 of 3 one-month dermatology curricula (didactic, clinical, or combined). The main outcome measure was performance on different sets of Medical Knowledge Self-Assessment Program (MKSAP)-15 questions at study entry and completion. A secondary outcome was self-rated performance in 3 clinical domains.
All participants completed the study. All curricula led to an improvement in MKSAP-15 scores, but only students who completed the didactic curriculum demonstrated a 20% improvement in posttraining scores. A larger number of residents completing the clinical and didactic curricula rated their clinical performance as improved compared to those who completed the combined curriculum.
While all 3 curricula led to improvement, as measured by a standardized assessment, a didactic curriculum in dermatology resulted in the largest improvement in knowledge as measured by a multiple-choice test.
大多数皮肤病患者由皮肤科以外专业的医生诊治,但大多数医生接受的皮肤科培训很少。
本研究的主要目的是确定完成三项指定课程之一后,内科住院医师的培训后分数是否会有大幅(20%)提高。次要目的是确定三个住院医师队列完成课程后在提高程度上是否存在显著差异。最后,我们探讨了住院医师课程结束后在感知临床知识方面的变化。
36名二年级内科住院医师被随机分配完成三项为期一个月的皮肤科课程之一(理论、临床或综合课程)。主要结局指标是研究开始和结束时在不同组别的医学知识自我评估计划(MKSAP)-15问题上的表现。次要结局是在三个临床领域的自我评估表现。
所有参与者均完成了研究。所有课程均使MKSAP-15分数有所提高,但只有完成理论课程的学生培训后分数提高了20%。与完成综合课程的住院医师相比,完成临床和理论课程的住院医师中更多人将自己的临床表现在完成课程后评为有所改善。
虽然通过标准化评估衡量,所有三种课程都带来了改善,但通过多项选择题测试衡量,皮肤科理论课程在知识方面带来的改善最大。