Olaniyan Janice O, Ghaleb Maisoon, Dhillon Soraya, Robinson Paul
Department of Pharmacy, School of Life and Medical Sciences, University of Hertfordshire, Hatfield, Hertfordshire, UK.
Int J Pharm Pract. 2015 Feb;23(1):3-20. doi: 10.1111/ijpp.12120. Epub 2014 Jun 22.
Medication errors are one of the leading causes of harmin health care. Review and analysis of errors have often emphasized their preventable nature and potential for reoccurrence. Of the few error studies conducted in primary care to date, most have focused on evaluating individual parts of the medicines management system. Studying individual parts of the system does not provide a complete perspective and may further weaken the evidence and undermine interventions.
The aim of this review is to estimate the scale of medication errors as a problem across the medicines management system in primary care. Objectives were: To review studies addressing the rates of medication errors, and To identify studies on interventions to prevent medication errors in primary care.
A systematic search of the literature was performed in PubMed (MEDLINE), International Pharmaceutical Abstracts (IPA), Embase, PsycINFO, PASCAL, Science Direct, Scopus, Web of Knowledge, and CINAHL PLUS from 1999 to November, 2012. Bibliographies of relevant publications were searched for additional studies.
Thirty-three studies estimating the incidence of medication errors and thirty-six studies evaluating the impact of error-prevention interventions in primary care were reviewed. This review demonstrated that medication errors are common, with error rates between <1% and >90%, depending on the part of the system studied, and the definitions and methods used. The prescribing stage is the most susceptible, and that the elderly (over 65 years), and children (under 18 years) are more likely to experience significant errors. Individual interventions demonstrated marginal improvements in medication safety when implemented on their own.
Targeting the more susceptible population groups and the most dangerous aspects of the system may be a more effective approach to error management and prevention. Co-implementation of existing interventions at points within the system may offer time- and cost-effective options to improving medication safety in primary care.
用药错误是医疗保健中危害健康的主要原因之一。对错误的审查和分析通常强调其可预防性和再次发生的可能性。在初级保健领域迄今为止进行的少数错误研究中,大多数都集中在评估药品管理系统的各个部分。研究系统的各个部分并不能提供完整的视角,可能会进一步削弱证据并破坏干预措施。
本综述的目的是估计初级保健中整个药品管理系统用药错误问题的规模。目标是:审查关于用药错误发生率的研究,并确定关于初级保健中预防用药错误干预措施的研究。
在1999年至2012年11月期间,对PubMed(MEDLINE)、国际药学文摘(IPA)、Embase、PsycINFO、PASCAL、科学Direct、Scopus、知识网络和CINAHL PLUS进行了系统的文献检索。搜索了相关出版物的参考文献以查找其他研究。
审查了33项估计用药错误发生率的研究和36项评估初级保健中错误预防干预措施影响的研究。本综述表明,用药错误很常见,错误率在<1%至>90%之间,具体取决于所研究的系统部分以及所使用的定义和方法。处方阶段最容易出错,65岁以上的老年人和18岁以下的儿童更容易出现严重错误。单独实施个体干预措施时,用药安全性仅略有改善。
针对更易受影响的人群和系统中最危险的方面可能是更有效的错误管理和预防方法。在系统内的各个点共同实施现有干预措施可能为提高初级保健中的用药安全性提供具有时间和成本效益的选择。