Degazon Cynthia E, Ben Natan Merav, Shaw Holly K, Ehrenfeld Mally
Hunter-Bellevue School of Nursing, Hunter College of City University of New York, NY, USA.
Pat Matthews Academic School of Nursing Hillel Yaffe Medical Center, Department of Nursing, School of Health Professions, Tel Aviv University, Tel Aviv, Israel.
Nurse Educ Today. 2015 Jan;35(1):57-62. doi: 10.1016/j.nedt.2014.05.016. Epub 2014 Jun 8.
In order to target new recruits or future generation of ethnic minority nurses about their potential fit in nursing, it is necessary to understand their perceptions of the profession. Successful recruitment of high school students into nursing in part requires congruency between perceptions of an ideal career and perceptions of nursing as a career. The purposes of this study were to compare ethnic minority high school students in the USA and in Israel on their perceptions of nursing as a career, and to understand how those perceptions compare to their perceptions of an ideal career.
A descriptive quantitative design was employed to study a sample of 330 ethnic minority high school students from the USA and from Israel.
The Mann-Whitney U procedure was used to compare the groups' perceptions; a two-sided Wilcoxon Signed-Ranks test was used to determine the differences between their perceptions of an ideal career and of nursing as a career.
The USA students had more positive perceptions of nursing as a career than did the Israeli students. Both groups of students did not perceive nursing as an ideal career: They perceived nurses as hard workers, performing arduous tasks and busy work, not academically challenged, with limited opportunity for leadership and autonomy, and earning less money than they would want in an ideal career. Caring for others was a highly valued attribute for an ideal career and for nursing as a career.
A minority career development plan that underscores the positive attributes of nursing should be designed in both the USA and in Israel for ethnic minority high school students. The plan should effectively communicate nursing as a caring profession that is academically rigorous and intellectually challenging with available leadership opportunities in institutions and society.
为了吸引新招募的或未来一代的少数族裔护士,使其了解自己是否适合从事护理工作,有必要了解他们对该职业的看法。成功招募高中生从事护理工作,部分需要理想职业认知与护理职业认知之间的一致性。本研究的目的是比较美国和以色列的少数族裔高中生对护理职业的看法,并了解这些看法与他们对理想职业的看法相比如何。
采用描述性定量设计,对来自美国和以色列的330名少数族裔高中生样本进行研究。
使用曼-惠特尼U检验来比较两组的看法;使用双侧威尔科克森符号秩检验来确定他们对理想职业和护理职业看法之间的差异。
美国学生对护理职业的看法比以色列学生更积极。两组学生都不认为护理是理想职业:他们认为护士工作努力,执行艰巨任务且工作繁忙,没有学术挑战,领导和自主机会有限,收入低于理想职业的预期。关爱他人是理想职业和护理职业中高度重视的特质。
美国和以色列都应为少数族裔高中生设计一个强调护理积极特质的少数族裔职业发展计划。该计划应有效地将护理传达为一个关爱他人的职业,在学术上严谨且智力上具有挑战性,在机构和社会中有可用的领导机会。