Leung Phuong, Orrell Martin, Orgeta Vasiliki
Division of Psychiatry, University College London, London, UK.
Int J Geriatr Psychiatry. 2015 Jan;30(1):1-9. doi: 10.1002/gps.4166. Epub 2014 Jul 3.
Despite the large number of studies evaluating social support groups for people with dementia, there are no systematic reviews of current evidence. The aim of this study was to evaluate the effectiveness of social support group interventions for people with dementia and mild cognitive impairment.
A systematic review was performed. We searched electronic databases for randomised controlled trials. Two reviewers worked independently to select trials, extract data and assess risk of bias.
A total of 546 studies were identified of which two met the inclusion criteria. We were not able to pool data for further analyses, as the interventions tested in the studies meeting the inclusion criteria were too dissimilar in content. The first trial (n = 136) showed a benefit of early-stage memory loss social support groups for depression and quality of life in people with dementia. The second trial (n = 33) showed that post-treatment self-reported self-esteem was higher in the group receiving a multicomponent intervention of social support compared with that in the no intervention control group.
Limited data from two studies suggest that support groups may be of psychological benefit to people with dementia by reducing depression and improving quality of life and self-esteem. These findings need to be viewed in light of the small number, small sample size and heterogeneous characteristics of current trials, indicating that it is difficult to draw any conclusions. More multicentre randomised controlled trials in social support group interventions for people with dementia are needed.
尽管有大量研究评估针对痴呆症患者的社会支持团体,但目前尚无对现有证据的系统评价。本研究的目的是评估社会支持团体干预对痴呆症患者和轻度认知障碍患者的有效性。
进行了一项系统评价。我们在电子数据库中检索随机对照试验。两名评价者独立工作以选择试验、提取数据并评估偏倚风险。
共识别出546项研究,其中两项符合纳入标准。由于符合纳入标准的研究中所测试的干预措施在内容上差异太大,我们无法汇总数据进行进一步分析。第一项试验(n = 136)表明,早期记忆丧失社会支持团体对痴呆症患者的抑郁和生活质量有益。第二项试验(n = 33)表明,与无干预对照组相比,接受社会支持多成分干预的组在治疗后自我报告的自尊水平更高。
两项研究的有限数据表明,支持团体可能通过减轻抑郁、改善生活质量和自尊对痴呆症患者产生心理益处。鉴于当前试验数量少、样本量小且具有异质性,这些发现需要谨慎看待,这表明很难得出任何结论。需要更多针对痴呆症患者社会支持团体干预的多中心随机对照试验。