Harrison Samantha Louise, Robertson Noelle, Apps Lindsay, C Steiner Michael, Morgan Mike D L, Singh Sally J
Pulmonary Rehabilitation Research Group, Department of Respiratory Medicine, University Hospitals Leicester NHS Trust , Glenfield Hospital, Leicester , UK .
Disabil Rehabil. 2015;37(9):750-6. doi: 10.3109/09638288.2014.939770. Epub 2014 Jul 10.
To explore how patients who refuse referral to pulmonary rehabilitation (PR) appraise acute exacerbations of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), in the context of having considered and declined PR.
Six participants recently hospitalized with an acute exacerbation COPD who refused a referral to PR subsequent to hospital discharge participated in in-depth interviews. Transcripts were subjected to interpretative phenomenological analysis (IPA).
Three conceptual themes emerged comprising: "Construction of the self", reflecting the impact of the acute exacerbation on personal identity; "Relinquishing control", describing participants" struggle to maintain agency following an acute event; and "Engagement with others", embodying participants' sensitivity and responsiveness to interactions with others.
Prominent in theses participants' narratives are self-conscious cognitions which appear founded in shame and stigmatization. These cognitions seem to reflect challenges to self-worth and appear associated with reduced help-seeking and isolation. Perceived personal culpability for COPD appears to sensitize participants' towards their interactions with health care professionals, construed as critical and judgmental which may increase avoidant behaviors, such as refusal of PR. When introducing PR, professionals should be aware of such sensitivities and facilitate open discussion which offers, time, compassion and understanding as a means of facilitating uptake.
Patients who decline referral to pulmonary rehabilitation report self-conscious cognitions (i.e., shame, guilt, fear of others evaluation) associated with lowered self-worth and reduced help-seeking. When introducing pulmonary rehabilitation health care professionals need to be mindful of patients' sensitivities to being shamed which stem from perceived culpability for COPD. Professionals should facilitate an open discussion with patients which offers, time, compassion and understanding as a means of facilitating pulmonary rehabilitation uptake. Compassion focused interventions which encourage trust and safety may promote active partnership working and facilitate engagement in pulmonary rehabilitation.
探讨拒绝接受肺康复(PR)转诊的患者在考虑并拒绝PR的情况下,如何看待慢性阻塞性肺疾病(COPD)急性加重。
6名因COPD急性加重近期住院、出院后拒绝PR转诊的参与者接受了深入访谈。对访谈记录进行了解释性现象学分析(IPA)。
出现了三个概念主题,包括:“自我建构”,反映急性加重对个人身份的影响;“放弃控制”,描述参与者在急性事件后努力保持自主性;“与他人互动”,体现参与者对与他人互动的敏感和反应。
在这些参与者的叙述中,突出的是自我意识认知,这些认知似乎源于羞耻感和污名化。这些认知似乎反映了对自我价值的挑战,并且似乎与求助减少和孤立感有关。对COPD的个人罪责感似乎使参与者对与医护人员的互动敏感,将其视为批评和评判,这可能会增加回避行为,如拒绝PR。在介绍PR时,专业人员应意识到这种敏感性,并促进开放的讨论,提供时间、同情和理解,以促进接受。
拒绝肺康复转诊的患者报告了与自我价值降低和求助减少相关的自我意识认知(即羞耻、内疚、害怕他人评价)。在引入肺康复时,医护人员需要注意患者因对COPD的罪责感而产生的被羞辱敏感性。专业人员应促进与患者的开放讨论,提供时间、同情和理解,以促进肺康复的接受。鼓励信任和安全感的以同情为重点的干预措施可能会促进积极的合作关系,并促进参与肺康复。