Inst. of Soil, Water and Environmental Sciences, Volcani Center, ARO, PO Box 6, Bet-Dagan 50250, Israel.
Inst. of Soil, Water and Environmental Sciences, Volcani Center, ARO, PO Box 6, Bet-Dagan 50250, Israel.
Sci Total Environ. 2014 Sep 15;493:995-1005. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2014.06.085. Epub 2014 Jul 9.
We tested the hypothesis that controlled deficit irrigation (CDI) of the fast growing, salinity resistant Eucalyptus camaldulensis tree with timely EDTA application can enhance sediment clean-up while minimizing leaching of metal complexes. 220-L lysimeters containing a sand-metal-polluted sludge mixture. Established saplings were irrigated with tap or desalinized (RO) water with/without 4-times daily addition of EDTA, EDDS and citric acid. In the 2nd season (2008/9) the chelates were added at 2 mM for ≈ 70 summer days. Diagnostic leaves and soil solution compositions were regularly monitored, the latter by applying prescribed leaching at an overall leaching percentage of ≈ 0.4%. While the three chelants solubilized sludge metals in batch extraction, EDDS often being the more efficient chelant, EDTA only was effective in the soil system. Leachate and leaves peak average concentrations in EDTA treatment vs. the control treatments were: Cd: 200 mg L(-1) vs. 1.0 and 67 vs. 21 mg kg(-1); Cu: 90 vs. 1.5 mg L(-1) and 17 vs. 3.0 mg kg(-1); Ni: 60 mg L(-1) vs. 14 and 20 vs. 6.0 mg kg(-1); Pb: >44 vs. 0.1 mg L(-1) and 9.0 vs. 1.0 mg kg(-1); and Zn: 650 vs. 4.0 mg L(-1) and 200 vs. 70 mg kg(-1), all respectively. Peak average leachate EDTA concentration was >60 mM, yet acclimating soil microflora gradually degraded most all the EDTA. In incubation study, EDDS and EDTA half-lives in acclimated lysimeter media were 5-11 days and ≥ 27 days, respectively. It suggests that sustainable phytoextraction of heavy metals is feasible under careful CDI with EDTA (yet not with biodegradable chelants) augmentation at low doses. Despite that the eucalypt was highly salinity (and EDTA) resistant, CDI using RO water further reduces soil solution salinity, thus increasing the usefulness of this remediation technique.
我们测试了这样一个假设,即在对生长迅速且具有较强耐盐性的桉树进行亏缺灌溉(CDI)的同时,适时施加 EDTA,可以在减少金属络合物淋洗的同时,提高沉积物的清理效果。实验采用 220 升的淋滤器,其中装有沙土-金属-污染污泥混合物。在实验中,对已定植的幼树进行灌溉,灌溉水采用自来水或反渗透(RO)水,且每日四次添加 EDTA、EDDS 和柠檬酸。在第二季(2008/9 年)中,添加 2 mM 的螯合剂,时间约为 70 天。定期监测诊断叶片和土壤溶液的组成,通过施加规定的淋洗,使淋洗率总体达到约 0.4%。三种螯合剂都可以在批处理提取中溶解污泥中的金属,而 EDDS 通常是更有效的螯合剂,而 EDTA 仅在土壤系统中有效。与对照处理相比,EDTA 处理的淋出液和叶片中的峰值平均浓度为:Cd:200mg/L 比 1.0 和 67 比 21mg/kg;Cu:90mg/L 比 1.5 和 17 比 3.0mg/kg;Ni:60mg/L 比 14 和 20 比 6.0mg/kg;Pb:>44mg/L 比 0.1 和 9.0 比 1.0mg/kg;Zn:650mg/L 比 4.0 和 200 比 70mg/kg。EDTA 的峰值平均淋出液浓度超过 60mM,但适应土壤的微生物群落逐渐降解了大部分 EDTA。在培养研究中,适应淋滤器介质中的 EDDS 和 EDTA 的半衰期分别为 5-11 天和≥27 天。这表明,在仔细的亏缺灌溉(但不能使用可生物降解的螯合剂)下,用 EDTA (而不是可生物降解的螯合剂)进行少量添加,重金属的可持续植物提取是可行的。尽管桉树对盐分(和 EDTA)具有很强的抗性,但使用 RO 水进行亏缺灌溉进一步降低了土壤溶液的盐分,从而增加了这种修复技术的实用性。