Hoffman S R, Dersarkissian R M, Buck S H, Stinziano G D, Buck G M
Buffalo Otological Group, University of New York.
Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 1989 Jun;100(6):573-7. doi: 10.1177/019459988910000609.
The efficacy of sinus surgery continues to be an issue of debate among otolaryngologists. In an attempt to address this controversy, a case-series study design was used to assess the perceived efficacy of sinus surgery in terms of the alleviation of sinus symptoms and overall health benefit. Self-administered questionnaires were mailed to 142 individuals who had sinus surgery performed between January 1984, and December 1985. After one follow-up attempt, 114 questionnaires were completed and returned (80% response). Overall, a high percentage of cases reported postoperative improvement in breathing difficulties (90%), nasal congestion (88%), headache/facial pain (85%), recurrent sinus infections (83%), and postnasal drip (80%). In addition, 88% of cases reported the surgery to be of some overall health benefit. These results suggest that sinus surgery, as perceived by surgically treated individuals, may be effective in the management of chronic sinus disease.
鼻窦手术的疗效一直是耳鼻喉科医生争论的焦点。为了解决这一争议,采用病例系列研究设计,从缓解鼻窦症状和整体健康益处方面评估鼻窦手术的感知疗效。自行填写的问卷被邮寄给1984年1月至1985年12月期间接受鼻窦手术的142名患者。经过一次随访尝试后,共收回114份填写并寄回的问卷(回复率80%)。总体而言,很大比例的患者报告术后呼吸困难(90%)、鼻塞(88%)、头痛/面部疼痛(85%)、复发性鼻窦感染(83%)和鼻后滴漏(80%)有所改善。此外,88%的患者报告手术对整体健康有一定益处。这些结果表明,接受手术治疗的患者认为鼻窦手术可能对慢性鼻窦疾病的治疗有效。