Stark Meredith, Fins Joseph J
Camb Q Healthc Ethics. 2014 Oct;23(4):386-96. doi: 10.1017/S0963180114000061. Epub 2014 Jul 17.
While the medical ethics literature has well explored the harm to patients, families, and the integrity of the profession in failing to disclose medical errors once they occur, less often addressed are the moral and professional obligations to take all available steps to prevent errors and harm in the first instance. As an expanding body of scholarship further elucidates the causes of medical error, including the considerable extent to which medical errors, particularly in diagnostics, may be attributable to cognitive sources, insufficient progress in systematically evaluating and implementing suggested strategies for improving critical thinking skills and medical judgment is of mounting concern. Continued failure to address pervasive thinking errors in medical decisionmaking imperils patient safety and professionalism, as well as beneficence and nonmaleficence, fairness and justice. We maintain that self-reflective and metacognitive refinement of critical thinking should not be construed as optional but rather should be considered an integral part of medical education, a codified tenet of professionalism, and by extension, a moral and professional duty.
虽然医学伦理文献已经充分探讨了医疗失误发生后对患者、家属以及行业诚信造成的危害,但较少涉及的是首先采取一切可行措施预防失误和伤害的道德与职业义务。随着越来越多的学术研究进一步阐明医疗失误的成因,包括在很大程度上医疗失误(尤其是诊断方面的失误)可能归因于认知因素,在系统评估和实施提高批判性思维技能及医学判断力的建议策略方面缺乏足够进展,这一问题日益受到关注。在医疗决策中持续未能解决普遍存在的思维错误,危及患者安全和职业素养,以及行善和不伤害原则、公平和正义。我们认为,对批判性思维进行自我反思和元认知的完善不应被视为可有可无,而应被视为医学教育的一个组成部分、职业精神的一项编纂原则,进而也是一项道德和职业责任。