Brown George R
Department of Psychiatry, East Tennessee State University, Johnson City, TN, USA
J Correct Health Care. 2014 Oct;20(4):334-42. doi: 10.1177/1078345814541533. Epub 2014 Jul 18.
Claims of inadequate health care and safety afforded to transgender inmates have become the subject of litigation. This article reviews 129 unsolicited letters from transgender inmates writing from 24 states and the Federal Bureau of Prisons to identify their concerns. Among the letters reviewed were reports from 10 inmates who had filed lawsuits naming departments of correction (DOCs) as defendants, claiming inadequate access to transgender health care. Five of these lawsuits have gone to trial. In all of those cases, the defendant settled the matter or was found liable as of the time of this report. Claims of inadequate care for transgendered patients that have sufficient merit to be fully litigated in U.S. courts appear likely to produce verdicts in favor of plaintiff inmates. The information gleaned from reviewing letters from transgendered inmates may alert staffs of DOCs to concerns worth addressing proactively to avoid the costs associated with transgender-related lawsuits.
关于变性囚犯获得的医疗保健和安全保障不足的指控已成为诉讼的主题。本文回顾了来自24个州和联邦监狱管理局的变性囚犯主动写来的129封信,以确定他们所关心的问题。在所审查的信件中,有10名囚犯的报告,他们提起诉讼,将惩教部门列为被告,声称获得变性医疗保健的机会不足。其中五起诉讼已经进行了审判。截至本报告撰写时,在所有这些案件中,被告都解决了问题或被判定有责任。在美国法院有充分价值进行全面诉讼的变性患者护理不足的指控,似乎可能会产生有利于原告囚犯的裁决。从审查变性囚犯的信件中收集到的信息,可能会提醒惩教部门的工作人员注意那些值得主动解决的问题,以避免与变性相关诉讼的成本。