Murthy Naveen S, Geske Jennifer R, Shelerud Randy A, Wald John T, Diehn Felix E, Thielen Kent R, Kaufmann Timothy J, Morris Jonathan M, Lehman Vance T, Amrami Kimberly K, Carter Rickey E, Maus Timothy P
Radiology, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, Minnesota, USA.
Pain Med. 2014 Oct;15(10):1686-94. doi: 10.1111/pme.12497. Epub 2014 Jul 7.
The aim of this study was to determine 1) if repeat lumbar transforaminal epidural steroid injections (TFESIs) resulted in recovery of pain relief, which has waned since an index injection, and 2) if cumulative benefit could be achieved by repeat injections within 3 months of the index injection.
Retrospective observational study with statistical modeling of the response to repeat TFESI.
Academic radiology practice.
Two thousand eighty-seven single-level TFESIs were performed for radicular pain on 933 subjects. Subjects received repeat TFESIs >2 weeks and <1 year from the index injection.
Hierarchical linear modeling was performed to evaluate changes in continuous and categorical pain relief outcomes after repeat TFESI. Subgroup analyses were performed on patients with <3 months duration of pain (acute pain), patients receiving repeat injections within 3 months (clustered injections), and in patients with both acute pain and clustered injections.
Repeat TFESIs achieved pain relief in both continuous and categorical outcomes. Relative to the index injection, there was a minimal but statistically significant decrease in pain relief in modeled continuous outcome measures with subsequent injections. Acute pain patients recovered all prior benefit with a statistically significant cumulative benefit. Patients receiving clustered injections achieved statistically significant cumulative benefit, of greater magnitude in acute pain patients.
Repeat TFESI may be performed for recurrence of radicular pain with the expectation of recovery of most or all previously achieved benefit; acute pain patients will likely recover all prior benefit. Repeat TFESIs within 3 months of the index injection can provide cumulative benefit.
本研究的目的是确定1)重复腰椎经椎间孔硬膜外类固醇注射(TFESI)是否能使自首次注射后逐渐减弱的疼痛缓解得以恢复,以及2)在首次注射后3个月内进行重复注射是否能实现累积获益。
对重复TFESI反应进行统计建模的回顾性观察研究。
学术性放射科。
对933名受试者进行了2087次单节段TFESI以治疗神经根性疼痛。受试者在首次注射后>2周且<1年接受重复TFESI。
采用分层线性模型评估重复TFESI后连续和分类疼痛缓解结果的变化。对疼痛持续时间<3个月的患者(急性疼痛)、在3个月内接受重复注射的患者(集中注射)以及同时具有急性疼痛和集中注射的患者进行亚组分析。
重复TFESI在连续和分类结果中均实现了疼痛缓解。相对于首次注射,在后续注射的建模连续结果测量中,疼痛缓解有最小但具有统计学意义的下降。急性疼痛患者恢复了所有先前的获益,且具有统计学意义的累积获益。接受集中注射的患者获得了具有统计学意义的累积获益,在急性疼痛患者中获益程度更大。
对于神经根性疼痛复发可进行重复TFESI,预期能恢复大部分或所有先前获得的获益;急性疼痛患者可能恢复所有先前的获益。在首次注射后3个月内进行重复TFESI可提供累积获益。