Keshet Yael, Schiff Elad, Samuels Noah, Ben-Arye Eran
Department of Sociology and Anthropology, Western Galilee Academic College, Galilee, Israel.
Psychooncology. 2015 Feb;24(2):169-74. doi: 10.1002/pon.3621. Epub 2014 Jul 15.
The aim of this study was to assess patient perspectives regarding non-specific effects of a complementary medicine (CM) consultation and intervention within an integrative oncology setting.
Patients undergoing chemotherapy in a community-based oncology service were referred by oncology healthcare providers to an integrative oncology physician trained in CM-oriented supportive care. Assessment of concerns and well-being was made using the Measure Yourself Concerns and Wellbeing questionnaire, at baseline and after 3 months of CM treatments, which were designed to improve quality of life (QoL) outcomes. Patients were asked to describe the most important aspects of the integrative treatment process. Free-text narratives were examined using content analysis with ATLAS.Ti software for systematic coding.
Of 152 patients' narratives analyzed, 44% reported an experience of patient-centered care, including CM practitioners' approach of togetherness, uniqueness, and the invoking of an internal process. CM practitioner approach was experienced within a context of an enhanced sense of confidence; gaining a different perspective; and acquiring emotional resilience and empowerment.
Short patient narratives should be considered for patient-reported outcomes, expressing perspectives of both effects and experience of care. CM may promote patient QoL-related outcomes through non-specific effects, enhancing patient-centered care. The benefits of CM dependent on general therapeutic incidental aspects (i.e., common factors) warrant attention regarding non-specific components of treatment.
本研究旨在评估患者对综合肿瘤学环境中补充医学(CM)咨询和干预的非特异性效果的看法。
社区肿瘤服务机构中正在接受化疗的患者由肿瘤医疗服务提供者转介给接受过CM导向支持性护理培训的综合肿瘤医生。在基线和CM治疗3个月后,使用“自我评估担忧与幸福感问卷”对担忧和幸福感进行评估,这些治疗旨在改善生活质量(QoL)结果。患者被要求描述综合治疗过程中最重要的方面。使用ATLAS.Ti软件进行内容分析以进行系统编码,对自由文本叙述进行检查。
在分析的152份患者叙述中,44%报告了以患者为中心的护理体验,包括CM从业者的团结、独特性方法以及引发内部过程。CM从业者的方法是在增强的信心感、获得不同的观点以及获得情绪恢复力和力量的背景下体验到的。
患者报告的结果应考虑简短的患者叙述,以表达护理效果和体验的观点。CM可能通过非特异性效果促进与患者QoL相关的结果,增强以患者为中心的护理。CM的益处取决于一般治疗附带方面(即共同因素),这需要关注治疗的非特异性成分。