Cha Seung-Whan, Kim Ik Yong, Kim Young Wan
Department of Radiology, Wonju College of Medicine, Yonsei University, Wonju, Korea.
Department of Surgery, Wonju College of Medicine, Yonsei University, Wonju, Korea.
PLoS One. 2014 Jul 22;9(7):e101292. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0101292. eCollection 2014.
Shear wave elastography (SWE) has not been studied for diagnosing appendicitis. We postulated that an inflamed appendix would become stiffer than a normal appendix. We evaluated the elastic modulus values (EMV) by SWE in healthy volunteers, patients without appendicitis, and patients with appendicitis. We also evaluated diagnostic ability of SWE for differentiating an inflamed from a normal appendix in patients with suspected appendicitis.
Forty-one patients with clinically suspected acute appendicitis and 11 healthy volunteers were prospectively enrolled. Gray-scale ultrasonography (US), SWE and multi-slice computed tomography (CT) were performed. The EMV was measured in the anterior, medial, and posterior appendiceal wall using SWE, and the highest value (kPa) was recorded.
Patients were classified into appendicitis (n = 30) and no appendicitis groups (n = 11). One case of a negative appendectomy was detected. The median EMV was significantly higher in the appendicitis group (25.0 kPa) compared to that in the no appendicitis group (10.4 kPa) or in the healthy controls (8.3 kPa) (p<0.001). Among SWE and other US and CT features, CT was superior to any conventional gray-scale US feature or SWE. Either the CT diameter criterion or combined three CT features predicted true positive in 30 and true negative in 11 cases and yielded 100% sensitivity and 100% specificity. An EMV of 12.5 kPa for the stiffest region of the appendix predicted true positive in 28, true negative in 11, and false negative in two cases. The EMV (≥12.5 kPa) yielded 93% sensitivity and 100% specificity.
Our results suggest that EMV by SWE helps distinguish an inflamed from a normal appendix. Given that SWE has high specificity, quantitative measurement of the elasticity of the appendix may provide complementary information, in addition to morphologic features on gray-scale US, in the diagnosis of appendicitis.
尚未对剪切波弹性成像(SWE)用于诊断阑尾炎进行研究。我们推测发炎的阑尾会比正常阑尾更硬。我们通过SWE评估了健康志愿者、非阑尾炎患者和阑尾炎患者的弹性模量值(EMV)。我们还评估了SWE在疑似阑尾炎患者中区分发炎阑尾与正常阑尾的诊断能力。
前瞻性纳入41例临床疑似急性阑尾炎患者和11名健康志愿者。进行了灰阶超声检查(US)、SWE和多层计算机断层扫描(CT)。使用SWE测量阑尾前壁、内侧壁和后壁的EMV,并记录最高值(kPa)。
患者分为阑尾炎组(n = 30)和非阑尾炎组(n = 11)。检测到1例阴性阑尾切除术病例。与非阑尾炎组(10.4 kPa)或健康对照组(8.3 kPa)相比,阑尾炎组的EMV中位数显著更高(25.0 kPa)(p<0.001)。在SWE以及其他超声和CT特征中,CT优于任何传统灰阶超声特征或SWE。CT直径标准或三项CT特征联合应用在30例中预测为真阳性,在11例中预测为真阴性,敏感性和特异性均为100%。阑尾最硬区域的EMV为12.5 kPa时,在28例中预测为真阳性,在11例中预测为真阴性,在2例中预测为假阴性。EMV(≥12.5 kPa)的敏感性为93%,特异性为100%。
我们的结果表明,SWE测量的EMV有助于区分发炎阑尾与正常阑尾。鉴于SWE具有高特异性,除了灰阶超声的形态学特征外,阑尾弹性的定量测量在阑尾炎诊断中可能提供补充信息。