Ophir A, Karakis I, Richter E D, Abarbanel J M, Wormser U, Aschner M, Finkelstein Y
Neurology and Toxicology Service and Unit, Shaare Zedek Medical Center, Jerusalem, Israel; Institute of Drug Research, School of Pharmacy, Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Israel.
Department of Environmental Epidemiology, Ministry of Health, Jerusalem, Israel.
Neurotoxicology. 2014 Dec;45:338-46. doi: 10.1016/j.neuro.2014.08.004. Epub 2014 Aug 13.
The natural history of chronic peripheral polyneuropathy following lifetime low-level organophosphate (OP) exposure was investigated. A pilot study (1984-1987) conducted in rural communities in Israel detected subtle reversible in-season changes in nerve conduction patterns of 17 field workers out of 214 residents exposed to seasonal drift containing OP's. We examined 60 individuals (males: 50/60; 83.3%) from the original cohort still residing (more than 40 years) in the same communities. Exposure assessment was based on reports by Israeli institutions and the Bureau of Statistics. Information on personal status, work experience, exposures and symptoms was collected by questionnaires. The nervous system was systematically studied, evaluating cortical upper motor neurons, corticospinal tracts, lower motor neurons and peripheral nerves. Electrophysiological studies included conduction velocities, amplitudes and distal latencies of sensory and motor median, ulnar, tibial and sural nerves; F-waves for proximal nerve functions; thermal and pain thresholds for small thinly-myelinated and non-myelinated fibers; transcranial magnetic stimulation for large fibers. Clinical and electrophysiological features of Carpal Tunnel Syndrome were found in 18% of the subjects, atypically in males only. Fingertips' tingling correlated with both axonal and myelin-dependent parameters (lower wave amplitudes and prolonged latency periods, respectively) in the sensory median nerves bilaterally. OP exposure significantly correlated to prolonged distal latency in the right median sensory nerve (r=0.29; p=0.052; n=45) and lower wave amplitude in the right sural nerve (p=0.031). These findings attest to subtle, predominantly sensory peripheral polyneuropathy following lifetime low-level exposures to drifts containing OP.
对终生低水平接触有机磷(OP)后慢性周围性多发性神经病的自然病史进行了调查。1984年至1987年在以色列农村社区进行的一项试点研究在214名接触含OP季节性漂移物的居民中,检测到17名田间工人的神经传导模式存在细微的可逆性季节性变化。我们检查了来自原队列的60个人(男性:50/60;83.3%),他们仍居住在同一社区(超过40年)。接触评估基于以色列机构和统计局的报告。通过问卷调查收集有关个人状况、工作经历、接触情况和症状的信息。对神经系统进行了系统研究,评估皮质上运动神经元、皮质脊髓束、下运动神经元和周围神经。电生理研究包括感觉和运动正中神经、尺神经、胫神经和腓肠神经的传导速度、波幅和远端潜伏期;近端神经功能的F波;细有髓和无髓小纤维的热阈值和疼痛阈值;大纤维的经颅磁刺激。18%的受试者出现腕管综合征的临床和电生理特征,仅在男性中表现不典型。双侧感觉正中神经中,指尖刺痛与轴突和髓鞘相关参数(分别为较低的波幅和延长的潜伏期)相关。OP暴露与右侧正中感觉神经远端潜伏期延长(r=0.29;p=0.052;n=45)和右侧腓肠神经波幅降低(p=0.031)显著相关。这些发现证明了终生低水平接触含OP漂移物后存在细微的、主要为感觉性的周围多发性神经病。