Shi F H, Fang L, Meng Q X, Wu H, Du J P, Xie X X, Ren L P, Zhou Z M, Zhou B
State Key Laboratory of Animal Nutrition, College of Animal Science and Technology, China Agricultural University, Beijing 100193, China.
State Key Laboratory of Animal Nutrition, College of Animal Science and Technology, China Agricultural University, Beijing 100193, China ; College of Animal Science, Tarim University, Alar 843300, China .
Asian-Australas J Anim Sci. 2014 Oct;27(10):1443-51. doi: 10.5713/ajas.2014.14057.
Increasing cost and scarcity of maize has stimulated the use of alternative feed sources (AFS) in the diets of cattle. In this study, we investigated the effects of partial or total replacement of maize on nutrient digestibility, growth performance, blood metabolites, and economics in Limousin crossbred feedlot cattle. Forty-five Limousin×Luxi crossbred bulls were randomly assigned to the three treatment groups, orthodox diet (OD; 45.0% maize), partial replacement diet (PRD; 15% maize, 67% AFS), total replacement diet (TRD; 0% maize, 100% AFS). The growth feeding trial lasted for 98 days. Dry matter intake (DMI) and average daily gain (ADG) were recorded. The digestion trial was carried out after the end of the growth trial. Total faeces and feed samples were measured daily. Digestibilities of dry matter (DM) and organic matter (OM), crude protein (CP), neutral detergent fiber (NDF) and acid detergent fiber (ADF) were calculated. After the feeding trial, blood metabolites were measured in 12 animals from each group. Initial and final body weights did not differ significantly among treatment groups (p>0.05). The ADG and DMI were 1.72 and 8.66, 1.60 and 9.10, and 1.40 and 9.11 kg/d for OD, PRD, and TRD, respectively. The PRD and TRD exhibited lower ADG (p<0.01) and higher DMI (p<0.01) than OD. The DMI (%body weight) was comparable between groups (p>0.5). Feed efficiency of PRD and TRD were lower than OD (p<0.01). The DM digestibility decreased with reduced level of maize (p = 0.10), OM digestibility was higher in OD (p<0.05), and CP, NDF and ADF digestibilities were similar for all groups (p>0.05). Blood urea nitrogen (mg/dL) in PRD and TRD was higher than OD (p<0.01), while other blood parameters did not differ significantly. Feed costs ($/head/d) were 1.49, 0.98, and 0.72 for OD, PRD, and TRD, respectively (p<0.01). Feed costs per kg gain ($) were significantly lower for PRD (0.63) and TRD (0.54) than OD (0.89; p<0.01). Overall profit ($/head) and daily profit ($/head/d) did not differ significantly between treatments (p>0.05), although TRD showed the highest economic benefits overall (p<0.01). While a traditional diet maximized the growth rate, partial or total replacement of dietary maize with AFS proved economically feasible due to their lower costs and comparable nutrient digestibilities of DM, CP, NDF, and ADF. Partial replacement may prove economically competitive in the current situation of China.
玉米成本的不断增加和供应短缺促使人们在牛的日粮中使用替代饲料来源(AFS)。在本研究中,我们调查了部分或全部替代玉米对利木赞杂交育肥牛的养分消化率、生长性能、血液代谢物及经济效益的影响。将45头利木赞×鲁西杂交公牛随机分配到三个处理组,即传统日粮组(OD;45.0%玉米)、部分替代日粮组(PRD;15%玉米,67%AFS)、完全替代日粮组(TRD;0%玉米,100%AFS)。生长育肥试验持续98天。记录干物质摄入量(DMI)和平均日增重(ADG)。生长试验结束后进行消化试验。每天测量总粪便和饲料样本。计算干物质(DM)、有机物(OM)、粗蛋白(CP)、中性洗涤纤维(NDF)和酸性洗涤纤维(ADF)的消化率。饲养试验结束后,测量每组12头牛的血液代谢物。各处理组的初始体重和终末体重差异不显著(p>0.05)。OD组、PRD组和TRD组的ADG分别为1.72、1.60和1.40kg/d,DMI分别为8.66、9.10和9.11kg/d。PRD组和TRD组的ADG低于OD组(p<0.01),DMI高于OD组(p<0.01)。各组间DMI(占体重的百分比)相当(p>0.5)。PRD组和TRD组的饲料效率低于OD组(p<0.01)。DM消化率随玉米水平的降低而降低(p = 0.10),OD组的OM消化率较高(p<0.05),所有组的CP、NDF和ADF消化率相似(p>0.05)。PRD组和TRD组的血液尿素氮(mg/dL)高于OD组(p<0.01),而其他血液参数差异不显著。OD组、PRD组和TRD组的饲料成本分别为1.49、0.98和0.72美元/头/天(p<0.01)。PRD组(0.63)和TRD组(0.54)每千克增重的饲料成本显著低于OD组(0.89;p<0.01)。各处理间的总利润(美元/头)和日利润(美元/头/天)差异不显著(p>0.05),尽管TRD组总体经济效益最高(p<0.01)。虽然传统日粮能使生长速度最大化,但由于AFS成本较低且DM、CP、NDF和ADF的养分消化率相当,因此用AFS部分或全部替代日粮中的玉米在经济上是可行的。在中国目前的情况下,部分替代可能在经济上具有竞争力。