Bristowe Katherine, Patrick Peter L
King's College London, Cicely Saunders Institute, Department of Palliative Care, Policy & Rehabilitation, London, UK.
Department of Language and Linguistics, University of Essex, UK.
Patient Educ Couns. 2014 Dec;97(3):347-51. doi: 10.1016/j.pec.2014.08.011. Epub 2014 Aug 26.
To explore use of 'Invitations to Ask Questions' (IAQs) by plastic surgeons in outpatient consultations, and consider how type of IAQ impacts on patients' responses to, and recollection of, IAQs.
Descriptive study: 63 patients were audio recorded in consultation with 5 plastic surgeons, and completed a brief questionnaire immediately after the consultation. Consultation transcripts were analyzed using inductive qualitative methods of Discourse Analysis and compared with questionnaire findings.
A taxonomy of IAQs was developed, including three types of IAQ (Overt, Covert, and Borderline). Overt IAQs were rarely identified, and almost all IAQs occurred in the closing stages of the consultation. However, when an overt IAQ was used, patients always recollected being asked if they had any questions after the consultation.
Patients are rarely explicitly offered the opportunity to ask questions. When this does occur, it is often in the closing stages of the consultation. Clinicians should openly encourage patients to ask questions frequently throughout the consultation, and be mindful that subtle differences in construction of these utterances may impact upon interpretation.
Clear communication, of message and intention, is essential in clinical encounters to minimize misunderstanding, misinterpretation, or missed opportunities for patients to raise concerns.
探讨整形外科医生在门诊会诊中使用“提问邀请”(IAQs)的情况,并考虑IAQ的类型如何影响患者对IAQ的反应及回忆。
描述性研究:对63名患者与5名整形外科医生的会诊进行录音,并在会诊结束后立即让患者填写一份简短问卷。使用话语分析的归纳定性方法对会诊记录进行分析,并与问卷结果进行比较。
制定了IAQ的分类法,包括三种类型的IAQ(显性、隐性和边缘性)。很少发现显性IAQ,几乎所有IAQ都出现在会诊的结束阶段。然而,当使用显性IAQ时,患者在会诊后总能回忆起被询问是否有问题。
患者很少有明确提问的机会。当这种情况确实发生时,通常是在会诊的结束阶段。临床医生应在整个会诊过程中公开鼓励患者频繁提问,并注意这些话语结构上的细微差异可能会影响理解。
在临床诊疗过程中,清晰传达信息和意图对于减少误解、错误解读或患者提出担忧的机会至关重要。