Geha Mental Health Center, PO Box 103, Petach-Tikva, 49100 Israel
J Clin Psychiatry. 2014 Aug;75(8):e817-23. doi: 10.4088/JCP.13m08823.
About 45% of civilians who died by suicide had contact with a doctor within 1 month of death. Thus, educating primary care physicians (PCP) to detect and mitigate depression is an important suicide-prevention strategy. However, the PCP consulting rate before suicide has not been examined in a military population. We investigated the utilization of primary health care and mental health services by active-duty military personnel suicide cases prior to death in comparison to matched military controls.
All suicides (N = 170) were extracted from a cohort of all active-duty Israeli military male personnel between 2002 and 2012. Applying a retrospective, nested case-control design, we compared primary care services utilization by suicide cases with demographic and occupationally matched military controls (N = 500).
Whereas 38.3% of suicide cases contacted a PCP within the last month before death, only 27.6% of suicide cases contacted a mental health specialist during their entire service time. The PCP contact rate within 1 month before death or index day did not differ between suicide cases and military controls (38.3% vs. 33.8%, χ²₁ = 1.05, P = .3). More suicide cases contacted a mental health specialist within service time than did military controls (27.6% vs. 13.6%, χ²₁ = 10.85, P = .001).
Even though PCP contact rate by military personnel who died by suicide is slightly lower than that reported for civilians who died by suicide prior to their death, it is higher than mental health specialist contact rate and higher than that by age-matched civilians who died by suicide. These results imply that PCPs education is a viable approach to suicide prevention in a military setting.
大约 45%的自杀身亡平民在死亡前 1 个月内曾与医生接触。因此,教育初级保健医生(PCP)发现和减轻抑郁是一项重要的预防自杀策略。然而,在军人人群中,自杀前 PCP 的咨询率尚未得到检验。我们调查了现役军人自杀病例在死亡前与匹配的军事对照组相比,对初级保健和精神卫生服务的利用情况。
从 2002 年至 2012 年期间所有现役以色列男性军事人员队列中提取所有自杀者(N=170)。应用回顾性嵌套病例对照设计,我们比较了自杀病例与人口统计学和职业匹配的军事对照组(N=500)的初级保健服务利用情况。
虽然 38.3%的自杀病例在死亡前 1 个月内曾接触过 PCP,但只有 27.6%的自杀病例在整个服役期间接触过心理健康专家。在死亡前 1 个月或索引日与军事对照组相比,PCP 的接触率(38.3%比 33.8%,χ²₁=1.05,P=0.3)没有差异。在服役期间,更多的自杀病例接触过心理健康专家(27.6%比 13.6%,χ²₁=10.85,P=0.001)。
尽管与之前自杀身亡的平民相比,死于自杀的军人与 PCP 的接触率略低,但高于与同龄平民自杀者的接触率。这些结果表明,PCP 教育是在军事环境中预防自杀的一种可行方法。