Kong A, Tussing-Humphreys L M, Odoms-Young A M, Stolley M R, Fitzgibbon M L
Institute of Health Research and Policy, University of Illinois at Chicago, Chicago, IL, USA; University of Illinois Cancer Center, Chicago, IL, USA.
Obes Rev. 2014 Oct;15 Suppl 4(0 4):62-92. doi: 10.1111/obr.12203.
Behavioural interventions incorporating features that are culturally salient to African American women have emerged as one approach to address the high rates of obesity in this group. Yet, the systematic evaluation of this research is lacking. This review identified culturally adapted strategies reported in behavioural interventions using a prescribed framework and examined the effectiveness of these interventions for diet and weight outcomes among African American women. Publications from 1 January 1990 through 31 December 2012 were retrieved from four databases, yielding 28 interventions. Seventeen of 28 studies reported significant improvements in diet and/or weight change outcomes in treatment over comparison groups. The most commonly identified strategies reported were 'sociocultural' (reflecting a group's values and beliefs) and 'constituent involving' (drawing from a group's experiences). Studies with significant findings commonly reported constituent-involving strategies during the formative phases of the intervention. Involving constituents early on may uncover key attributes of a target group and contribute to a greater understanding of the heterogeneity that exists even within racial/ethnic groups. Available evidence does not, however, explain how culturally adapted strategies specifically influence outcomes. Greater attention to defining and measuring cultural variables and linking them to outcomes or related mediators are important next steps.
纳入对非裔美国女性具有文化显著性特征的行为干预措施,已成为解决该群体高肥胖率问题的一种方法。然而,对这一研究缺乏系统评价。本综述使用规定框架确定了行为干预中报告的文化适应性策略,并研究了这些干预措施对非裔美国女性饮食和体重结果的有效性。从四个数据库中检索了1990年1月1日至2012年12月31日期间的出版物,共获得28项干预措施。28项研究中有17项报告称,与对照组相比治疗组在饮食和/或体重变化结果方面有显著改善。报告中最常确定的策略是“社会文化”(反映群体的价值观和信仰)和“参与成分”(借鉴群体的经验)。有显著结果的研究通常在干预的形成阶段报告了参与成分的策略。早期让成分参与可能会揭示目标群体的关键属性,并有助于更深入地理解即使在种族/族裔群体内部也存在的异质性。然而,现有证据并未解释文化适应性策略如何具体影响结果。下一步重要的是更加关注定义和测量文化变量,并将它们与结果或相关中介联系起来。